CreateDebate


Debate Info

1
5
No 21st Yes 21st
Debate Score:6
Arguments:6
Total Votes:6
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 No 21st (1)
 
 Yes 21st (5)

Debate Creator

mechanic(66) pic



18th and 21st Amendments

The 18th amendment prohibited the making and selling of alcohol. The 21st amendment repealed that, allowing the making and selling of alcohol, did the U.S Government make a mistake making the 21st?

No 21st

Side Score: 1
VS.

Yes 21st

Side Score: 5
No arguments found. Add one!
1 point

I've travelled in 15 countries. Non of them had anything like the 18th. I was supposed to travel to two Muslim countries which live under an 18th (or similar). Both of those trips got cancelled, one because they blew up the plant I was going to, another because they started killing people in the streets. I'll live with the 21st, thank you. (Very much).

Side: Yes 21st
cruzaders(341) Disputed
1 point

In muslim countries such as Algeria or Marocco consumption is illegal but selling it to tourists is legal (in reality everybody drinks alcohol but everyone refuses to admit it)

Side: No 21st
1 point

Adults should be allowed to put whatever substance they please into their own body and live with the consequences. Aside from the fact that prohibition can't work without a totalitarian state, it simply doesn't make sense to take away somebody's agency when nobody else is being harmed.

Side: Yes 21st
1 point

Not disagreeing, but the 18th technically didn't prohibit consumption. It targeted production, distribution, and sales. I think that's also objectionable, but it opens up a bit more room for the position seeming reasonable.

Side: Yes 21st
1 point

Ah but if you cannot brew or buy alcohol, then how are you to consume it? I do appreciate the distinction though, I was interested to see that it doesn't appear that possession itself was criminalized.

Side: Yes 21st
1 point

We could link to all the harm attributed to alcohol. So the concept of the 18th banning it isn't totally without merit. It's just the reason prohibition was imposed was far more moral than practical, and in a country based heavily on freedom it's just really hard to justify why all the people who use alcohol without abusing it somehow have to give it up completely.

Side: Yes 21st