CreateDebate


Debate Info

4
16
Spartans Samurai
Debate Score:20
Arguments:10
Total Votes:24
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Spartans (4)
 
 Samurai (6)

Debate Creator

wpillor(58) pic



300 Spartans vs. 300 Samurai

"Hand-to-hand tactics"

Spartans

Side Score: 4
VS.

Samurai

Side Score: 16
0 points

If the spartans could take on hundreds of thousands of persians I'm sure the samurais wouldn't be too hard.

Side: Spartans
2 points

mmm, yes, but you also have to look at the terrain tactics. Thermopylae was fought around narrow cliffs, terrain that favoured heavy, unified infantry, whereas the samurai train for open combat, with emphasis on mobility and speed. I'm sure given the right circumstances the Spartans can win, but such terrain is very specific and generally unavailable.

Side: Samurai
0 points

watch the movie if you havent then dicide

Side: Spartans
-1 points
I went to Broad Run High School.... go Spartans!
Side: Spartans
4 points

sighs you just can't beat the ninja status of the samurai.

zOMG ninja parade !! :DDDDD

Side: Samurai
3 points
Srsly? Can the other side even be debated successfully?
7 Samurai > 300 Spartans
What chance do the Spartans have against 300!?
Supporting Evidence: Duh (en.wikipedia.org)
Side: Samurai
1 point

The samurai only have strong armor & swords. They also live in a peaceful culture.

The Spartans are trained from childhood & are given the hardest training.

The Persians used all sorts of weapons & warfare against the Spartans & the Spartans still beat them.

The samurai would put up a big fight against the Spartans but the Spartans would win in the end.

Side: Spartans
3 points
Samurai would definitely dominate this one. The Spartans wouldn't even know what hit them. Kind of like the Modesto California citizens who turn out each year for the Ninja Parade. See link.
Supporting Evidence: Ninja Parade Slips Through Town Again (www.theonion.com)
Side: Samurai
2 points

This type of parade needs to take place in more areas.

Side: Samurai
1 point

I have heard that if you accidentally touched a samurai they would cut you in half with their sword on the spot. Even children.

Plus this is just to spite that retarded movie.

Side: Samurai