CreateDebate


Debate Info

3
11
Yes No
Debate Score:14
Arguments:13
Total Votes:14
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Yes (2)
 
 No (11)

Debate Creator

hammertime(165) pic



A compulsory abortion come to youth pregnancies

Yes

Side Score: 3
VS.

No

Side Score: 11

I'm not allowed to drive because I don't have the motor skills or maturity to safely handle a vehicle - it puts both my and other peoples lives at unnecessary risk. Why shouldn't pregnancy be the same?

Why should I be allowed to bring a child into this world, with no resources or job security, my brain not even fully developed yet?

Side: yes
catticus90(360) Disputed
1 point

Since the word 'youth' is very broad ranging anywhere from 13 to 34 by area definition it's unfair to assume that all youths are minors. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Youth

Although in developed countries this age range generally refers to teenagers but does actually include ages up to 24. Although I shall assume for argument purposes that your are making reference to teenagers (correct me if I'm wrong).

Your argument is largely based on stereotype. If you make reference to my opposing argument you will see that I was pregnant at 19. My partner and I were both secure financially so we got a house and went ahead with the pregnancy. My daughter has everything she needs and more not just financially but emotionally. Not to mention biologically my body age was optimal for child bearing and birth. Take for instance that at woman at 40 carries a much greater risk of health problems to her and her baby why should I be denied a pregnancy and she granted one?

Age has little to do with parenting capability. My argument posed that a 16 year, or even younger, could be the most loving, hard working, committed parents. Then you could take a 30 year old drug addict who would beat their child. Why should the good teenage parent be denied the pregnancy because the grandparents would provide financially while a terrible parent who would completely destroy their child's life be granted the pregnancy simply because they are older?

You're also making the assumption that all teenagers have no resources or jobs. I've worked since I was 15 and been in secure employment since 16 as have other teenagers. Particularly by 19 many have secure jobs if they are not in university or college education.

Side: No

Up to 34? Right, I understand that now, and when you had your child, you were well setup. However, I still don't think extremely young girls, as in preteens, should have their baby - they're just not mentally capable. Such young pregnancy also suggests a negative social background (there's been studies) and to bring a child into that, with probably little support and educational and health care opportunity, it's just a little selfish.

Side: No
1 point

No, for someone so young has such an experience is bad enough and if they also have a child must get it only gets worse.

Side: No
1 point

I'm somewhat in favour of compulsory abortions for any woman who is clearly incapable of financing the costs of raising a child, or for some other reason is unlikely to raise their child well (e.g. someone who is a known child abuser or substance abuser).

But not all teen pregnancies fall into this category.

Side: No
1 point

It would be ridiculous and seriously infringe human rights. For starters it is healthier to bare a child at age 16 than at age 40 why should a mature adult who is biologically less capable of following through a healthy pregnancy be favored over a biologically safer pregnancy?

I personally don't think age is a reflection on parenting ability. A youth parent could be loving, self sacrificing, hard working and a good role model. An older parent could be a drug addicted child abuser (Just to clarify I'm not suggesting all youth parents are good and mature parents are bad, this is purely a valid example).

How is youth pregnancy classed? Socially it's a teenage pregnancy. I was 19 when I fell pregnant with my daughter. My partner and I moved in together, got engaged and we both already had secure jobs. We're a wonderful family unit, why should I be forced to abort when I have the emotional and financial capability to support a child?

Even in poor circumstance I don't believe a youth should be forced to abort. My mother had me at 16, moved into social housing at 18 and heck we were dirt poor. But my mother went back to college got a decent job and has always been an amazing parent to me. Who's to say a bad situation cannot be improved? Especially with the positive influence and drive of having a child.

Side: No
1 point

No! Of course not! When you become pregnant, you should be able to make a choice on what you do. I'm not supporting youth pregnancies but there are very many teen moms who do the best that they possibly can to raise a child and make sure the child has the best. Not every teen mother is incapable. Abortion would completely violate a girl and it should be her choice, not the governments, on what she does to her body.

Side: No

Considering the situation is different for every parent...I would still say no, no one should force any such experience upon anyone. Given circumstances I believe it should be a choice of the carrier. However if they are too young to understand such things I believe a parent should speak with them on the matter.

Side: No