CreateDebate


Debate Info

3
5
Yes. No.
Debate Score:8
Arguments:8
Total Votes:10
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Yes. (3)
 
 No. (3)

Debate Creator

KJVPrewrath(967) pic



Abortion is murder unless the mother's life is in danger?

Yes.

Side Score: 3
VS.

No.

Side Score: 5
1 point

Yes.. abortion is murder... because by doing so you are killing a innocent life... murder means killing a living being it can be 20 year old human, a street dog or any other living things. we make the laws as per over safety.

so we can not say killing a street dog is not murder.. it is murder but their life is not much important for us so don't care..we defined level of killing as per their importance and power. same places in world killing poor people is also not accountable,no one their to inquire about them so we can not say that's not a murder.

same a baby inside mother's womb has a life and because he/she can not speak, show you his/her pain does not mean we can kill him/her.

Side: Yes.
1 point

I don't think it is a "life" until it takes the breath of life. I don't go along with abortion with no GOOD reason, but I do respect a woman's right, her choice.

Side: No.
KJVPrewrath(967) Disputed
1 point

Evidence from any source please...................................................................................................

Side: Yes.
AlofRI(3294) Clarified
1 point

No evidence needed to have an opinion, that is mine........

Side: Yes.

Murder is defined as, "the unlawful premeditated killing of one human being by another." So, since abortion isn't currently unlawful it's not murder, but for the sake of argument let's assume abortion was illegal. Would it then be murder? It depends on when the abortion is performed, and here's why I think that. Consciousness is what makes me a person. Without a functioning brain my life is no more meaningful than that of an amoeba. That's why we pull the plug on people who are brain dead. Their body may technically still be alive, but the thing that makes them who they are, consciousness, is gone. The parts of the brain that are required for consciousness don't develop in a fetus until the third trimester. So as long as the abortion is done before the fetus has developed consciousness I don't think it's murder.

Side: No.
1 point

Murder actually means killing which is against the law, as abortion isnt illegal ,foremost thing its not murder..as on debate point i still beleive its not murder because , murder is killing of life ..and life will be started after breath of the external atmosphere ...ofcourse life reaction been started yet its not the so called life which human being in law beleives ...and aborting is stopping undesired and not specifically murder...

Side: No.
Patidar(62) Disputed
1 point

Dear.which law you are taking about. the law created by human as per their safety..

suppose, if law allow to kill people so after that time killing people also will not murder.

friend murder means killing a living being. it can be anything who can breath, law allow that killing or not does not matter.

Side: Yes.