CreateDebate


Debate Info

1
3
facts but mein anusol medication
Debate Score:4
Arguments:13
Total Votes:6
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 facts (1)
 
 but mein anusol medication (2)

Debate Creator

God-(96) pic



Amarel believes in voodoo

I saw him sacrificing information to the Gods, but they were not pleased. They told him he needed to bring them something tangible like neurochemicals and electricity or they would steal his soul and throw it down the nearest volcano.

facts

Side Score: 1
VS.

but mein anusol medication

Side Score: 3
-1 points

Information relies on physical material but is not itself physical. Despite the non-material nature of information, it exists and is fundamental to reality. Furthermore, information has a direct impact on physical phenomena and results in indirect causation.

The mystical faith of strict materialism disallows acknowledging the above. Yet if a strict materialist responds to this (or any) post, they tacitly agree, as they have physically been caused to respond by the non-material information contained in these physical pixels. Thus they demonstrate their own incoherence.

Side: facts
God-(96) Disputed
2 points

Prove that comprehending words requires an intangible substance called information. In reality you are nothing but a big, fat retarded sack of shit.

I can see the physical shapes with my physical eyeballs that my physical neurons physically associate with physical things that are physically represented in the brain by physical interactions making me physically able to read your physical retardation. Even abstract concepts are physical because the conceptual world you live in is made of chemicals and electricity and your subjective experience is nothing but a bunch of physical sensory feedback loops and notions derived from your subjective experience of it which all boil down to what you experience and how your physical brain reacts to it.

Side: but mein anusol medication
Amarel(4968) Clarified
0 points

Prove that comprehending words requires an intangible substance called information.

Comprehension is itself non-material, as is the idea of proving. Can you tell me how a comprehension physically looks? No.

I can see the physical shapes with my physical eyeballs that my physical neurons physically associate with physical things that are physically represented in the brain by physical interactions making me physically able to read your physical retardation.

First off, you can see. That’s the experience of consuming light data and deriving information there from. Physical interaction with non-physical information does not make information physical.

Even abstract concepts are physical because the conceptual world you live in is made of chemicals and electricity

That’s like saying the number “2” is made up of these pixels. No concepts are physical including abstract concepts. (Abstract literally means “existing in thought or as an idea but not having a physical or concrete existence“. I had to give you the definition of metaphysical earlier. Keep being pissy and I may stop educating you)

The brain state that composes the information of your experience of the color red is not itself red. It’s a physical organization that carries the information of red. The information of red, which is non-material. If it were material, you could know that I see red the same as you. You can’t know that. Even if you could observe the identical brain state associated with red in my brain as in yours, you could not know that the information is experienced the same. Your experience of color is no more material than your experience of any other data or information derived from the physical world. Experience is as non-material as the information that composes it.

Side: facts
1 point

Information relies on

Information doesn't rely on anything because it isn't trying to be information. It's jaw-dropping watching your elaborate efforts to try to disguise the fundamentally obvious fact that you're an idiot.

Side: but mein anusol medication
No arguments found. Add one!