CreateDebate


Debate Info

97
20
Dogs are smart - why? Dogs are kinda
Debate Score:117
Arguments:27
Total Votes:148
Ended:11/14/17
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Dogs are smart - why? (19)
 
 Dogs are kinda (8)

Debate Creator

mrswillits(9) pic



This debate has ended. You can no longer add arguments or vote in this debate.

Are Dogs Dumb? (In response to our 6th grade article on animal intelligence.)

In response to our 6th GRADE ARTICLE on Animal Intelligence of DOGS - entitled, "Are Dogs Dumb?" - please pick a position and defend it with evidence from the article.  You can make a case for both sides if you want to, but you must use something to support your claim!  (A debate without reasoning is just a yelling match! A debate with reasoning is a conversation!)

FOR ANYONE ELSE FINDING THIS DEBATE - PLEASE UNDERSTAND IT IS FROM AN ARTICLE WE ARE READING IN 6th Grade LANGUAGE ARTS ON RESEARCH WITH ANIMAL INTELLIGENCE and the COOL STUFF they discovered about dogs!  Please post, if you do, responsibly and appropriately.  

Dogs are smart - why?

Side Score: 97
Winning Side!
VS.

Dogs are kinda

Side Score: 20
8 points

I believe that dogs are not dumb. My reason for my decision is because I find it smart of the dogs to be able to hear a command and follow it based on the outcomes.

Side: Dogs are smart - why?
8 points

They are smart in their own way because they don't really approach new things but they remember old ones.

Side: Dogs are smart - why?
2 points

Rabiesboy nice! So right. I also think that they can do tricks too.

Side: Dogs are smart - why?
8 points

Dogs are smart

Dogs are very smart, compared to cats. Dogs can be trained to be police dogs, drug sniffing dogs, shepherds, therapy dogs, guard dogs, and many other things as well. The idea that cats are smarter than dogs is not always true.

Are dogs smart?

Side: Dogs are smart - why?
7 points

I think dogs are smart, because they can be trained to find things, help people in need, and even normal dogs can be good alert dogs! I have two dogs who bark at EVERYTHING, so they would make good alert dogs if something happens.

Side: Dogs are smart - why?
8 points

I completely agree Sarah, dogs can be trained to do almost anything, they can save live if they are taught how to.

Side: Dogs are smart - why?
7 points

I think dogs have the ability to learn and be smart. Like we have taught our dogs to get outside the gate. It was a good thing when we did not have a lock on it, now it is so so. But I do think dogs are smart if they chose and if they are taught.

Side: Dogs are smart - why?
7 points

I honestly think that dogs are smart because they are able to learn tricks, for example, "a dog might be clever enough to fetch his leash when he wants to go out."

Side: Dogs are smart - why?
6 points

On page 14 it says, "Dogs are much smarter than chickens, its probably because dogs are good at learning the things we want them to learn. for example: you can teach a dog to fetch but try doing that with a chicken."

Side: Dogs are smart - why?
6 points

Now, I just want to say something here. Say someone is snowboarding and they get trapped in ice and snow, the rescue team wont be able to find them unless they have a rescue dog with them. THINK ABOUT THAT!!!

Side: Dogs are smart - why?
5 points

Dogs may not be as intelligent as other animals, but they are not dumb. Dogs know what they need to know for them to live. In the article it said, "All animals have the ability to learn things that are important to them" "Otherwise they wouldn't survive" Each animal has different skills and abilities, so if they were to make a test to see if every animal was smart or not, it wouldn't be fair. " Even if you could find a test that was perfectly fair to all animals, in a way it's silly to ask whether one kind of animal is smarter than another."

Side: Dogs are smart - why?
5 points

I think dogs are smart because they can be trained to do amazing things like sense that a robber is ne'er.

Side: Dogs are smart - why?
4 points

I don't really think dogs are smart but I don't think they are dumb either...

Side: Dogs are smart - why?
4 points

They are smart because my dog remembers everything!! We normally give him a treat when he comes in the garage. The days we don`t, he walks over towards the fridge looking at me like im a idoit. GIMME A TREAT. He is saying in his head. He knows when someone comes up the diveway and protects me and family. I think he is a smart dog there a many other things he does that are smart i think he is very smart.

Side: Dogs are smart - why?
3 points

I am sort of on the fence, but dogs are smarter than they seem, being able to hunt their own food, but they also do some stupid things. (like chase their own tail)

Side: Dogs are smart - why?
2 points

I think dogs are smart because of many reasons. One reason I'm just saying because a great majority of people think dogs chase their tail because they are dumb, but its really mostly because they are bored and need play or a walk. (My cat chases her tail when she is extremely bored, or wants attention, and she is very smart) Dogs can help people do stuff too, like more that the 'go get the newspaper and go get your leash and yada yada yada'. I have a link to a video that I will use to support my reasons, and I will give the link in just a minute. A fun fact: Scientists have agreed that the most intelligent breed of dog is the Border Collie. They most of the time herd sheep, but that doesn't prove anything. I don't even know what I'm saying now! :P So here's the link, of a 2 minute video of a Border Collie Aussie (Australian Sheppard) Mix, named Secret, doing household chores and yoga and stuff with her owner, Mary.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-479SFi3mcQ

Side: Dogs are smart - why?
1 point

If dogs were dumb why would there be a fire dog, a police dog and dog's that find people that got stuck in snow and dogs that literally see for SOMEBODY! if dogs were dumb then we are dumb to have a dumb "man's best friend"!!!

Side: Dogs are smart - why?
2 points

I do not thinks dogs are completely dumb, but I wouldn't call them smart. On page 14 on the right side it says "The truth is, most dog tricks take advantage of dogs' built-in behavior patterns-things that dogs are born knowing how to do or learn easily." I think if any animal were manipulated and their skills were used for domestic things then they would be considered "smart" too. Also I think people have softened up to dogs because they are pets, but are they really smart? I am not saying they are dumb, but they are smarter than any other average animal.

Side: Dogs are kinda
1 point

I don't think they're dumb but I don't think they're smart either...

Side: Dogs are kinda
0 points

I agree with you, Orrin, dogs are not dumb or smart, it is a tough choice.

Side: Dogs are kinda
1 point

There dumb because it says that dogs with chase there tails for hours. It also says they had to remove a dog from the canine IQ test because the dog was scared of the yellow cap. Or that the would bark at thing if they make a sound. This is why I think dogs are dumb.

Side: Dogs are kinda
benmellinger(4) Disputed
1 point

dogs are not dumb, but they are not extrordinarily smart. SOME might chase their tales, but that is only some. Have you ever really seen a dog chase its tale for hours. also the yellow lid test was designed for monkeys, so they removed the yellow lid to make it for dog friendly. DOgs are not dumb but they are not smart.

Side: Dogs are smart - why?
1 point

I also want to add that on page 14 it also shows a game the dogs do as a test. They didn't do good on the one designed for chimps but did good on the one designed for them. I think if any test was built for a animal it would do just as good as the dog did.

Side: Dogs are kinda
0 points

I think dogs a pretty dumb because dogs dont really do anything for you.

Now chickens they lay eggs attack people you dont like and are very good company.

All dogs do is bark make messes and annoy people now i like some dogs but not all of them .

Side: Dogs are kinda
-1 points

I think dogs are also kinda dumb, because they need much training to be able to do what you want them to do, and I have dogs that think they are cats. And dogs are actually kind of dumb, because of the dog test that it says in the reading, they may not be as smart as we hope. And as I said, mine act like cats ALL THE TIME!

Side: Dogs are kinda
2 points

I understand what you are saying Sarah they have to chose to be smart.

Side: Dogs are kinda
ChristopherO(6) Disputed
1 point

I think you're kind of wrong in this one, because my father tells stories about how his dog could sense him coming home from way down a hill. That's an inate instinct.

Side: Dogs are smart - why?