CreateDebate


Debate Info

15
19
Women are more responsible Women aren't more responsible
Debate Score:34
Arguments:18
Total Votes:38
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Women are more responsible (8)
 
 Women aren't more responsible (10)

Debate Creator

Pineapple(1443) pic



Are women natually more responsible than men?

Since we're doin' the whole "Men are from Mars, Women are from Venus" thing....

It seems to me that women are naturally more suited to planning, saving, and accepting responsibility than men.

Is this a item of tradition, passed on from mother to daughter? Is it societal? Is it instinct?

Or is it simply not true?

Women are more responsible

Side Score: 15
VS.

Women aren't more responsible

Side Score: 19
6 points

It actually makes more sense to me that women would be more responsible than men in practical life. But, this would only be in the case of two mature adults, one woman and one man. Not the teenage girls who are probably the most irresponsible things out there (teenage boys can be too, but girls do some evil, stupid shit).

But back to the point, women are built to be more careful through evolution. Men have to be daring because they have to go out and hunt and create for the benefit of the mother and child. Women have to be careful and responsible because they have to take care of the child while the man is out hunting. She must watch the child, which takes planning and careful responsibility. He must provide for the mother and child, which takes daring boldness.

Evolutionary Psychology and Sexology... fuckin' awesome subjects to study.

4 years ago | Side: Women are more responsible
0mrlolman0(18) Disputed
2 points

I believe you are confusing maturity and personal choice with responsibility. They are quite different things, in reality. Men and women both have complete potential to be responsible, and of course maturity and age influences this, but it is, in fact, not exclusively prevalent to either gender.

4 years ago | Side: Women aren't more responsible
ThePyg(6745) Disputed
3 points

I guess you didn't read my post. It had nothing to do with maturity. It has to do with evolutionary classes.

4 years ago | Side: Women are more responsible
1 point

I am going to say: They are more responsible.

I mean, biologically standing, they were built to protect, nurture, and feed children...

And that takes responsibility.

I think somehow they must be more responsible or else we'd have a lot more head injuries. And we can all say: Guys aren't the most attentive people on Earth.

4 years ago | Side: Women are more responsible
1 point

men are more responsible than women in terms of being responsible in their decisions. is it true? please help

2 years ago | Side: Women are more responsible
1 point

Of course not in all cases no. But in general women are. Men are more reckless, better problem solvers, better decision makers.

182 days ago | Side: Women are more responsible
-1 points

Why are woman getting better and better jobs everyday? And why is it that women have many more things to do than men?THEY ARE MORE RESPONSIBLE!!! Men are worth less and men know this, thats why this debate started in the first place!

4 years ago | Side: Women are more responsible
Raven01(10) Disputed
2 points

Why are women getting better jobs?

Because MEN are changing the rules so that women can hold a job with lower qualifications. Police, military, firefighting, EMT's, you know the people that you rely on when everything goes bad.

Women also spend about 80% of ALL disposable income. Yes, their disposable income AND men's disposable income is spent (often quite foolishly) by women. That is why the majority of marketing (tricking idiots into buying crap they don't need) is directed at women.

Feminism also dictates that women are always victims. Victims are never RESPONSIBLE.

While feminism by no means speaks for all women, a large enough portion of women identify with feminism therefore cannot possibly be responsible.

2 years ago | Side: Women aren't more responsible
Adameve(1) Disputed
1 point

first of all, lets stop being programmed as most are with religion.....eve didnt listen to god...that's maturity for you. woman think with emotions...emotions can cloud judgments...that seems real mature.....woman have more excuses than man..really mature females.....guys just wanna have fun...girls want everything, thats mature....Most females pick the wrong mate...thats mature.

2 years ago | Side: Women aren't more responsible
AngryGenX(458) Disputed
1 point

First of all. Our economy is morphing from one of substance to one based on services and government wastefulness. Such an economy favors women. When was the last time you met a ship riveter or someone who works at a steel mill

The government encourages companies to hire women. Every time a company hires a man over a woman they risk a law suit, while the opposite is never true.

In jobs that do require physical strength disregard capabilities in favor of equality. Maybe 1% of all women are capable of overpowering a below average man. Does that stop them from being prison guards, police officers, or soldiers and putting the people they work with in danger?

182 days ago | Side: Women aren't more responsible

While men are out earning a living, women are at home doing yoga or Pilates ;)

4 years ago | Side: Women aren't more responsible
1 point

Exactly Joe! Hence my other debate: "Yoga or Pilates?"

But it's what we do with yoyr earnings that make us responsible!

4 years ago | Side: Women aren't more responsible
cookiemonsta(1) Disputed
1 point

I'm sorry but not all girls are like that in fact we are more responsible and we do get jobs we fight in wars we are cooks cause god knows men don't like cooking cause it's "the girls job" sorry but thats a bunch of bull girls push babies out! we have a once a month visitor that we hate, do you no all you do is carry a dick around in your pants

182 days ago | Side: Women are more responsible

All you women want is the D. That's why they are always wearing skin tight or skimpy clothes. They pictures of their boobs half hanging out and post it on the internet. ;)

182 days ago | Side: Women are more responsible

This debate is extremely partial to women. The question and answers.

4 years ago | Side: Women aren't more responsible
2 points

I don't believe that women are inherently more responsible than men: but it is proven that biologically they mature at a faster rate than men. Being more mature at a younger age can provide a false sense of increased responsibility.

Long story short, maturity does not equait responsiblility.

4 years ago | Side: Women aren't more responsible
2 points

What an ill themed statement. Define Responsible?

Both women and men have their clearly defined roles as spelled out via a millenia of historical fact. Whether you agree or disagree with said roles is moot.

I gather one needn't be too intelligent to enter a question for debate on this site?

4 years ago | Side: Women aren't more responsible
1 point

I don't believe that women are inherently more responsible than men: but it is proven that biologically they mature at a faster rate than men. Being more mature at a younger age can provide a false sense of increased responsibility.

Long story short, maturity does not equait responsiblility.

3 years ago | Side: Women aren't more responsible


About CreateDebate
The CreateDebate Blog
Take a Tour
Help/FAQ
Newsletter Archive
Sharing Tools
Invite Your Friends
Bookmarklets
Partner Buttons
RSS & XML Feeds
Reach Out
Advertise
Contact Us
Report Abuse
Twitter
Basic Stuff
User Agreement
Privacy Policy
Sitemap
Creative Commons
©2014 TidyLife, Inc. All Rights Reserved. User content, unless source quoted, licensed under a Creative Commons License.
Debate Forum | Big shout-outs to The Bloggess and Andy Cohen.