CreateDebate


Debate Info

Debate Score:31
Arguments:23
Total Votes:37
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Atheists hailed Hawkings as rather intelligent after he threw a moronic jab/line at God (23)

Debate Creator

jeffreyone(1383) pic



Atheists hailed Hawkings as rather intelligent after he threw a moronic jab/line at God

"Can God create a rock so heavy that he himself can not lift it?"
There is a common sense answer to this thing that so called intelligent people backing the statement could not think out.
The question most probably arises from the attribute of God; OMNIPOTENT.

So the first line of the question says
"Can God create"
Yes, God *can* because he is OMNIPOTENT(all powerful or can do everything).
The second line says
"that he himself *_can not_*"
Cannot means impotent. 
Now my question is,
Where or when did God say he is impotent that you question the degree his impotency instead his degree of potency which is actually His attribute (OMNIPOTENT not Omni-impotent)?  

Add New Argument
1 point

I'll bet Stevie is having some second thoughts right now.

1 point

Wow, you muddle minded sad sacks sure do love gibberish.

"Faith is believing what you know ain't so." - Mark Twain

outlaw60(15368) Disputed
5 points

You muddle minded sad sacks sure do love gibberish.

Rusty are you making reference to yourself and your party ????????

outlaw60(15368) Disputed
5 points

Rusty you came to be by two apes procreating ?????? Is that what you call Mommy and Daddy ?

1 point

Oh dear Jeffrey has returned and if anything I thought your previous state of stupidity could not be surpassed but in fairness you’re still devolving rapidly .

Can God create a rock so heavy that he himself can not lift it?"

There is a common sense answer to this thing that so called intelligent people backing the statement could not think out.

The question most probably arises from the attribute of God; OMNIPOTENT.

So the first line of the question says

"Can God create"

Yes, God can

Gods omnipotence includes the power to do the logically impossible according to indoctrinated sheeple like you

I’m all clear so far and you agree emphatically that your god can create a rock so heavy he cannot lift it because he can, because he’s Omnipotent , but even a god cannot make a square Circle so you’re basically agreeing your god is illogical which to me was a given anyway

jeffreyone(1383) Disputed
1 point

The question testing God brings both His attribute (OMNIPOTENT) and it's direct contradiction impotence(cannot) together to achieve a result making a stupid a question. It's like you say you are Irish then why would I ask you about your Indian family? When you never said you are an Indian; that would make it a stupid question just like the God and Stone silly rhetoric.

Dermot(5736) Disputed
1 point

What babble is this? You’re making absolutely no sense you idiotic beast

jeffreyone(1383) Disputed
1 point

Can you be a cassava farmer and make it bear mango fruits?

Dermot(5736) Disputed
1 point

Can a Ghanaian dummy be educated?...........................

1 point

Where or when did God say he is impotent that you question the degree his impotency instead his degree of potency which is actually His attribute (OMNIPOTENT not Omni-impotent)?

God didn't say that, because God is a fictional character, to whom we (humans) apply our convenient attributes for the purpose of feeling morally and intellectually superior, and ignore the supposed attributes that we do not like or that do not fit our worldview. Not only do we baselessly assume that this character called "God" exists, we assume it is the only one of it's kind, that it created us, listens to us, or even notices or cares about us, based on the unverified word of superstitious people thousands of years ago (which can hardly even be called witnesses with any credibility) and edited time and time again by the church.

But that's just my two cents. Hey, if you want to let your life revolve around a god, that's not my problem.

Amarel(5669) Banned
0 points

Since when is a question a jab line?

Can an omnipotent being create something more powerful than itself? That question doesn’t address the degree of potency, but rather it’s limits. Which is why you avoided an attempt at an answer. You prefer to ridicule the question.

jeffreyone(1383) Disputed
1 point

It's an even more stupid question because God's attribute omnipotence means infinite in power. How can any mentally sound person ask if there could be something greater than infinity(unlimited).

Amarel(5669) Disputed Banned
0 points

omnipotence means infinite in power. How can any mentally sound person ask if there could be something greater than infinity

It’s ok to say that you don’t believe god can do the logically impossible. Unless you do believe it, in which case you should say so. The question isn’t whether there may be something greater than infinity, the question asks if God’s infinite power means he can create something more powerful than himself. He either can or he cannot. Which is it?

justicebaker(9) Disputed
-3 points