CreateDebate


Debate Info

9
9
Atheists are religious zealots Not zealots
Debate Score:18
Arguments:17
Total Votes:20
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Atheists are religious zealots (8)
 
 Not zealots (9)

Debate Creator

brontoraptor(28599) pic



Atheists have become the new religious zealots

Since I have been on this site, I have had Atheists galore try to tell me what is "moral" or "right" and even condemn me for being "not very polite", despite the fact that Atheism has no objective morality to claim, and says it hates others ramming their beliefs down their throats. Atheists have become the modern day Pharisee priests of 2017.

Atheists are religious zealots

Side Score: 9
VS.

Not zealots

Side Score: 9
2 points

indeed .......................... I believe the actions from athesitc "chemical over-reactions" doeth prosteth too much

Side: Atheists are religious zealots

You dont need objective morality to make moral judgements. We all use our own subjective moral codes to make judgements.

Side: Not zealots
0 points

Atheism has no objective morality to claim

You're suggesting a god is required to have objective morality? Has this ever been demonstrated? Has it ever been shown to be impossible without a god?

My question to you: Is something moral because God said so, or does God say so because it's moral? If the former is true, then whatever God says is moral, goes. If God one day says it's okay to slaughter innocent children, then "morality" has no meaning. If the latter is true - that God says so because it's moral - then there must be some foundation for moral truth out there which would render God irrelevant.

Side: Not zealots
1 point

So tell us what it is while not ramming your beliefs down our throats. (giggle)

Side: Atheists are religious zealots
0 points

You just admitted that you have no objective morality. You finally speak the truth.

Side: Not zealots
seanB(950) Disputed
1 point

Nobody has any objective morality. That's the point.

What's objective about believing (without any proof) in the stories of shepherds from thousands of years ago: stories concerning an unseeable, invisible, untestable, unquantifiable entity that arbitrates in all human affairs: stories which are thus far, continually challenged and disproved in many areas by testable scientific facts and theories?

There's nothing objective in "faith", Cartman, nor in any morality derived from it.

Side: Atheists are religious zealots
Cartman(18192) Disputed
1 point

I know that. You know that. Christians, like bronto, don't know that.

Side: Not zealots