CreateDebate


Debate Info

24
24
They are They are not
Debate Score:48
Arguments:44
Total Votes:52
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 They are (22)
 
 They are not (21)

Debate Creator

brontoraptor(28599) pic



Babies are bigots

Babies show racial bias, study finds

Babies are more likely to choose playmates of their own ethnicity in a phenomenon known as 'in-group bias'

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/science/science-news/10770563/Babies-show-racial-bias-study-finds.html

They are

Side Score: 24
VS.

They are not

Side Score: 24

Of course they are. If everyone was born reasonable, there are a lot of things we wouldn't have.

Side: They are
2 points

There's nothing to say that they haven't learned it. If you're a child and all you see every day are white people, white people become the norm. That isn't to say children or babies who spend most of their time around white people are racists. A baby doesn't consider black people inferior as a race, nor do they harbour angst, aggression, or hatred for black people. They simply gravitate towards what they know and understand. If you expose a white baby to black caregivers, the baby will not respond the same as a baby who has only been exposed to white caregivers.

Hold the phone, Sherlock Holmes.

Side: They are
1 point

And... you... voted for the very position that you argued against. I'll take the points though.

Side: They are not

Looks like we have killed the Left's claim that "racism is taught. Children learn it. They aren't born that way." Of course that might explain why they call Conservative blacks "Uncle Toms". They are mad that the black man didn't fall in line.

Side: They are
1 point

Whoa people! There is a difference between gravitating towards your own race, and hating other races.

Side: They are

The article itself, which states a test that was administered, says that? Babies are bigots.

Side: They are
4 points

Nope. In fact my own kids are in a day care with mixed races and pretty much everybody plays nicely with everybody else.

Furthermore, kids are nervous about pretty much anything new to them. Put a new food in their lunch box and they'll probably eat everything else first. That doesn't mean they hate what they didn't eat yet, just that it's new to them and they're kids.

Side: They are not
1 point

So liberal hatred of the white race isn't baby bigotry, but rather, indoctrination.

Side: They are
Grenache(6053) Disputed
0 points

Hatred by babies, or of babies, in either case, really doesn't exist. There is simply babies still getting used to their world, as well as whatever that world is exposing them to.

Side: They are not
1 point

Racism isn't born into a baby, it's developed. When babies start to get used to their environment and the world, then the signs of racism begin to show.

Side: They are not
0 points

Children that young are not capable of major autonomous thought. They'll naturally be attracted to things that they are familiar with - which obviously means black children would be more afraid or reluctant of white children, and vice versa. It could be considered a survival instinct... afraid of strangers, loving of trusted and known people.

Being afraid of the unknown doesn't mean you hate the unknown. Once they discover it, they relish in it. Racism is most certainly taught - attempting to argue otherwise is attempting to justify it.

Side: They are not
1 point

Not really. The left has been teaching children to hate white people for a while now. I'd blaim it on baby bigots rather than indoctrination if I were you.

Side: They are
0 points

No. Bigotry is a taught. My children play quite nicely with the other kids at daycare. They don't care about gender or skin color, they only care about which toy to play with and when.

They can certainly be suspicious of change or different things but not at the level of being labeled a bigot.

Side: They are not
1 point

So... liberal bigotry and hate of the white race is due to indoctrination, not instincts/baby bigotry.

Side: They are
Mint_tea(4641) Disputed
0 points

I think bigotry of any kind would and could be a product of circumstance, teaching, and experience.

Side: They are not