CreateDebate


Debate Info

13
1
wtf, No way! Yes, save the babies!
Debate Score:14
Arguments:9
Total Votes:14
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 wtf, No way! (8)
 
 Yes, save the babies! (1)

Debate Creator

JustIgnoreMe(1064) pic



Ban coffee for all women?

If caffeine is an abortifacient, should it be outlawed for all potentially pregnant women?

http://www.jstor.org/pss/3702858

http://www.amazing-green-tea.com/drinking-green-tea-when-pregnant.html

http://www.likhaan.org/sites/default/files/pdf/2008_facts_contraception_abortion.pdf

If abortion becomes illegal in all circumstances and life begins at conception, does drinking coffee become a negligent homicide?

wtf, No way!

Side Score: 13
VS.

Yes, save the babies!

Side Score: 1
2 points

Life carries with it risk, a risk of miscarriage below a cut off shouldn't be denied to pregnant women and shouldn't be denied to all women, because the risk doesn't justify the restriction in such cases. A very large amount would have to be consumed often in order for the risk to be considerable.

From your second source " Caffeine can reduce birth weight and cause miscarriage, but this is significant only for 600 milligrams of caffeine. This is equivalent to 6 cups of coffee a day.

Another study based in Denmark arrived at similar conclusion. They interviewed more than 88,000 pregnant women. Moderate consumption was found to be safe.

However, drinking more than 8 cups or more of coffee a day increases the chances of miscarriage or still birth by 60%. "

While your 3rd source states that 3 or more cups may be significant.

At most, the data supports a limitation of intake for pregnant women, of one to two cups a day.

2 years ago | Side: wtf, No way!
2 points

Coffee has numerous health benefits. While drinking it during pregnancy (not "potentially pregnant" which is highly ambiguous) is not recommended by doctors because of the caffeine, drinking outside of pregnancy can be quite good for the drinker when done in moderation.

As stated before, "potentially pregnant" is a highly ambiguous term which could refer to someone who thinks she is pregnant or someone who may become pregnant at some point. It would be like banning alcohol from all women in the range of childbirth ages. Additionally, there would be no practical way to enforce this law (or most other prohibition laws for that matter) considering our already faltering/failing war on drugs (which we can all say is probably a bit more important, even if a bit misguided, than a war on coffee).

Link: http://www.health.harvard.edu/press_releases/coffee_health_risk

Link: http://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2008/06/080616170839.htm

Link: http://www.cnn.com/2011/09/26/health/women-depression-coffee/index.html

2 years ago | Side: wtf, No way!

Banning coffee is definitely not necessary, what for? Coffee although contains caffeine, have you seen many people dying from drinking coffee rather than smoking?

In addition, there is numerous health benefits from drinking coffee.

2 years ago | Side: wtf, No way!

It is about time that women make responsible choices, and if it not drinking coffee during pregnancy, then so it be.

2 years ago | Side: wtf, No way!
1 point

If women have the right to kill their [unborn] child at will, then they should likewise have the right to harm (if that's the right word, which I doubt) themselves in such a manner that may - but in all likelihood won't - kill their child.

2 years ago | Side: wtf, No way!

I guess I should have been more clear in the debate description - what I am meaning to ask is the inverse question.

If abortion becomes illegal, would 'harm' also become illegal?

2 years ago | Side: wtf, No way!
1 point

I think they should ban coffee because a lot of women and men drink it everyday and are addicted to having a lot of coffee. I would ban it because it is not healthy at all.

2 years ago | Side: Yes, save the babies!
casper3912(1553) Disputed
3 points

It has positive antioxidant effects, and like most things is only unhealthy in large amounts. Even water is toxic if you have enough of it. People have the right to make themselves unhealthy, so long as doing such doesn't do the same to society. Drinking large amounts of coffee often, isn't going to have a negative enough effect on society to justify it's ban.

2 years ago | Side: wtf, No way!
Sitara(11099) Disputed
2 points

Coffee in moderate or small amounts can be healthy. .

340 days ago | Side: wtf, No way!


About CreateDebate
The CreateDebate Blog
Take a Tour
Help/FAQ
Newsletter Archive
Sharing Tools
Invite Your Friends
Bookmarklets
Partner Buttons
RSS & XML Feeds
Reach Out
Advertise
Contact Us
Report Abuse
Twitter
Basic Stuff
User Agreement
Privacy Policy
Sitemap
Creative Commons
©2014 TidyLife, Inc. All Rights Reserved. User content, unless source quoted, licensed under a Creative Commons License.
Debate Forum | Big shout-outs to The Bloggess and Andy Cohen.