CreateDebate


Debate Info

Debate Score:63
Arguments:39
Total Votes:78
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Can a Jew be a German Muslim? (44)

Debate Creator

Factocracy(346) pic



Can a Jew be a German Muslim?


Add New Argument

If they renounce Judaism to become a full-fledged Muslim, yes? I'm an agnostic/atheist and if I convert, I can become a Jew/Christian/Muslim.

Factocracy(346) Clarified
2 points

@HighFalutin

Exactly, because Judaism is a religion and not a race. That is why Excon is retarded, because he is an Atheist who is genetically Polish and if any Hebrew blood runs through his veins at all it is only a trace amount. It would be equally ridiculous for him to point to the one percent of Nigerian DNA he has and use it to justify a claim that his race is African voodoo.

excon(18260) Clarified
1 point

It would be equally ridiculous for him to point to the one percent of Nigerian DNA he has and use it to justify a claim that his race is African voodoo.

Hello hater:

So, you BELIEVE the Nigerian part of my DNA, but not the Jewish part.. Dude! That's fucking nuts.

excon

PS> I'm done here.. DNA IS science.. That's just so. Arguing that it isn't, is STUPID, STUPID, STUPID..

excon(18260) Disputed
1 point

If they renounce Judaism to become a full-fledged Muslim, yes? I'm an agnostic/atheist and if I convert, I can become a Jew/Christian/Muslim.

Hello High:

So, you're a science denier too??? Who knew?

https://www.myheritage.com/dna/ethnicity/intro/D9R7CP1FCT9JGSRI5T87ACI8E1KMGH1LEKRNKM9BCDMNKQ3GE9JK4LAC6HD38R25F5SJ4DRPE50KUQ3ACL878JI2CD732GR2ED732MG?utm

You should understand that BEFORE I took the DNA test, I too didn't believe that Judaism was a race. But, the RESULT speaks for itself..

Or, you could DENY the results, if you believe like the haters do, that the Jewish owned DNA lab had a stake in LYING, because well, they're Jews after all... But I don't think you're quite that nuts..

excon

Factocracy(346) Disputed
1 point

That DNA test doesn't even link you to Israel. When you say Judaism is a race the only possible way you can justify it is to conflate "Jew" with "Hebrew" and the DNA test doesn't even quantify how much Hebrew DNA you have.

1 point

I didn't know ethnicity was a race.

----------------------------------------

Can a Jew be a German Muslim?

Sure. But instead of white guilt, it would take Jewish self hate.

-2 points
Factocracy(346) Disputed
2 points

If Jew is a race, why are there blond haired blue eyed genetically "Aryan" Jews? Why can you be a Muslim Aryan Jew?