CreateDebate


Debate Info

2
5
Of course you moron Not even close.
Debate Score:7
Arguments:5
Total Votes:8
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Of course you moron (2)
 
 Not even close. (2)

Debate Creator

pizzakitty(68) pic



Can the extreme left wing be classified as communist?

???????????
                 ?
                   ?
                     ?
                        ?
                            ?
                               ? 
                             ?
                          ?
                        ? 
                    ?
                  ? 
              ?
            ?
          ?
         ?
         ?
         ?
         



         ??
         ??

Of course you moron

Side Score: 2
VS.

Not even close.

Side Score: 5

Yes.

They believe in near 0% money in the pocket of the individual and near 100% money in the pocket of the government.

Side: Of course you moron
AlofRI(2794) Clarified
1 point

No. What we believe in is being a TEAM with the government OF, BY, and FOR the people. We want to pay taxes, but we want our moneys worth. Military strong enough to defend U.S., clean air, clean water, clean food, a clean and safe neighborhood, health care (like the rest of the industrialized world), OUR SHARE of the nations money, not the occasional "drip down" from those that return the 80+% of the nations to banks overseas, not to the country that allowed them to make it! How can 300,000,000 Americans have much money in their pockets when we have to divide 12 - 18% of the nations money between U.S. while 1-2% invest a pittance in America, much more in foreign countries and foreign banks! Don't give me that CRAP about higher taxes than the rest of the world! The taxes paid in other countries LOOK lower, but the other "fees" imposed in other countries make U.S. a better (or equal) deal! We want a percentage of money in the government, enough to "make America great" (and a great place to live and work in) ... and we would have that IF that 1-2% paid their fare share, and corporations wouldn't spend more on financiers and lawyers to get OUT of paying those "terrible taxes" than they spend on the taxes!

What we DON'T need is Trump's "tax relief for the middle class" ... that ISN'T! Tax relief for the middle class that destroys what little health care we have left after he refused to "fix" the ACA, just because Obama FINALLY got what he COULD, and hoped conservatives would work FOR THE PEOPLE to improve it! Instead, that money GOES TO THE GOVERNMENT to build a stupid wall and defend U.S. from those in the world he is PISSING OFF .... and we will likely do it alone because our "allies" have been pissed of as well!

It's true, we "liberals" want things different, but certainly NOT ANYTHING resembling "communism"! A government of, for and BY the people is NOT communism! The Trump/Bannon visage is FAR closer to THAT!

Side: Of course you moron
1 point

But the debate is about extreme left, not about you.

Side: Of course you moron
3 points

"a theory or system of social organization in which all property is owned by the community and each person contributes and receives according to their ability and needs" I have seen many extreme left wingists in my life and none of them has ever told me he was for any of this

Side: Not even close.
2 points

Well, I'm not extreme left wing, but, since there is little RIGHT wing that is NOT extreme, anyone on the left LOOKS extreme to them. They are SOOO far to the right, the left looks extremely far away. No matter, 99 and 44/100ths of the left wing HATES communism, so NO, we CAN NOT be classified as communist. If you weren't SOOO far to the right you could SEE this.

We also are SOOO far to the LEFT (from YOU) that we can't see those "very good people" walking with the "white nationalists and skinheads" of the Steve Bannon camp, we'd need special, right wing glasses to see them, (Trump sells them ... made in China) ... or maybe it's just that we DON'T want to see them! Just stubborn, I guess ... or we don't like uglies.

Side: Not even close.