CreateDebate


Debate Info

7
2
You can It's impossible
Debate Score:9
Arguments:8
Total Votes:9
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 You can (6)
 
 It's impossible (2)

Debate Creator

brontoraptor(11789) pic



Can you die from a smell?


         


You can

Side Score: 7
VS.

It's impossible

Side Score: 2

Sure. Anything in excess is poison.

Side: You can
Hamzantal(4) Disputed
1 point

How so? How can smelling too much orange be deadly? This doesn't make any sense. This is about smell! That is not how it works my friend!

Side: It's impossible
1 point

Excluding any chances of suffocation, or including it?

Though you can die another way, suffocation is the most likely one, because it's quick.

Side: You can
Impirum(59) Disputed
1 point

You don't know what does 'excess' mean. Everything excessive has to be poisonous, which is a constant law. Some of the things are only far from excession, but nothing can't be excessive. For this matter, if the smell is extremely concentrated? If you smell it for hundreds of years (despite the life) ?

Side: You can
1 point

How so? How can smelling too much orange be deadly?

Yes. Agent orange killed thousands of people.

Side: You can
1 point

You can die from Brontos smell.

Side: You can
1 point

I believe, that as smell, you mean it is very unpleasant, and not a deadly chemical like poison or gas.

No. An Irritating smell can't kill you. The smell will 'get used' to the person, and the person will start ignoring the smell. If there is a smell of rotten flesh nearby, it may make you sick from the disgusting smell, but that is because biologically we tend to try to stay away from harmful chemicals and bad things. So no, I don't think that anyone should be able to die by smell.

Side: It's impossible
1 point

What if it CAN kill you? What then Hamzantal? *

Side: You can