CreateDebate


Debate Info

9
14
Yes No
Debate Score:23
Arguments:22
Total Votes:23
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Yes (8)
 
 No (14)

Debate Creator

joecavalry(33148) pic



Could a lot of grief had been avoided if the U.S. had created Israel in its borders?

If, before the start of WW II, The U.S. had taken every German Jew and given them American soil where they could have built a state, then the halocaust as we know may have been averted and the Israeli/Palestinian conflict would be no more.  Maybe some south western state that borders Mexico ;)

Yes

Side Score: 9
VS.

No

Side Score: 14

Whatever issues the new Israel would have, it would not compare to the last 100 year history. ;)

2 years ago | Side: yes
1 point

I say we should have given them New Jersey. oh wait a second........

2 years ago | Side: yes

What exit ;)

2 years ago | Side: yes
1 point

that's a very interesting question. The only problem i see with that is that terrorism was created to make money and steal resources all over the world. Without Israel as an imaginary Holy land Christianity would not be the wood added to the fire. War....is money. The future is planned 30 years at a time. I have a question for ya...."Grief for who"? What or who's grief could have been avoided and under what circumstances would Zionists have even agreed to that proposition? Jews and Germans own our money,our commerce our courts and both the house and our senate. They own our satellites, our communication systems and our military might. The only Grief i see is the collateral casualties needed to advance and control education and natural resources. May the good Lord bless Israel and the current order of things. If you are a free thinker read Revelations the 17th chapter the king James version. A pattern of events has been shaping for some time now.

2 years ago | Side: yes
1 point

Com'on Joe....you know damn well that Israel has had that capability since the early 1990's. Do you really think that "anything" that we have is hidden from Israel? Jews own how information is distributed worldwide. They keep requesting different technologies from us openly to leave the "IMPRESSION" that they have limited capabilities.

2 years ago | Side: yes
1 point

Just give them Kansas, no one's using it anyway, I mean, other than a few guys driving their pickups into tornadoes and Billy Bob's gunmart.

2 years ago | Side: yes

Jews have always found trouble, no matter where they go ;)

2 years ago | Side: No
1 point

I think ur talking about the holocoust being avoided right if so then no i think if they had moved it would hav been some other minority group and they would hav picked on the and blamed thm for there problems because hitler just wanted a scape goat

2 years ago | Side: No
1 point

We should have just had them live in the USA, basically the same thing, they just remain a part of our country.

2 years ago | Side: No
1 point

U.S didn't create Isreal, the British Empire did.

2 years ago | Side: No
Qymosabi(156) Disputed
1 point

The u.s. played a very criticle role in the creation of Israel. You cannot exclude or diminish the impact and importance of U.S. support of Jewish people and the creation of Israel.

Supporting Evidence: History of/Israel/palestin/Truman (www.trumanlibrary.org)
2 years ago | Side: yes
Axmeister(4295) Disputed
1 point

YOu cannot just ignore the fact that Isreal was created as a mandate for the British Empire, if the U.S hadn't been so big on self-independancy for countries maybe Isreal might still be protected.

2 years ago | Side: No
1 point

I'm a little bit confused by that as well...I think maybe what he means is that if the U.S. had set aside some land for a Jewish state, some of the current violence could have been avoided. Although arguably that may just create anti-semitism in whoever is already living there.

2 years ago | Side: No

That is a correct interpretation. Somebody already suggested we should have given them Kansas. I would have selected Chicago ;)

2 years ago | Side: No
1 point

The reason Jews choose to remain in Israel is because of its religious background and significance to Judaism. I'm not sure they would really want to do this.

2 years ago | Side: No


About CreateDebate
The CreateDebate Blog
Take a Tour
Help/FAQ
Newsletter Archive
Sharing Tools
Invite Your Friends
Bookmarklets
Partner Buttons
RSS & XML Feeds
Reach Out
Advertise
Contact Us
Report Abuse
Twitter
Basic Stuff
User Agreement
Privacy Policy
Sitemap
Creative Commons
©2014 TidyLife, Inc. All Rights Reserved. User content, unless source quoted, licensed under a Creative Commons License.
Debate Forum | Big shout-outs to The Bloggess and Andy Cohen.