CreateDebate


Debate Info

4
8
Sounds GOOD to me It's a commie plot
Debate Score:12
Arguments:13
Total Votes:12
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Sounds GOOD to me (4)
 
 It's a commie plot (6)

Debate Creator

excon(18261) pic



Do right wingers LOVE flat taxes?? If SS taxes were FLAT, SS would be solvent FOREVER

Hello:

Social Security taxes are capped around $150,000.  In other words, everything you make BEYOND $150,000, is SS tax FREE. That means the RICH pay a much SMALLER percentage of their income in Social Security taxes than POOR people do..

But, if we FLATTENED the tax so that EVERYBODY pays the SAME rate, Social Security would be SOLVENT forever. 

What's wrong with that??

excon

Sounds GOOD to me

Side Score: 4
VS.

It's a commie plot

Side Score: 8
1 point

I've always said I'm completely fine with a flat tax so long as it truly gets applied to everyone and everything equally and that if any cheats get caught they then have to pay through the nose as punishment.

Side: Sounds GOOD to me
2 points

So long as the government continues to misappropriate SS funds for other uses, SS is doomed. Putting more money into it would simply mean more money can be misused. The problem isn't funding.

That being said, a flat tax would be better for all taxes including SS. At least until we have a privatized alternative.

Side: It's a commie plot
outlaw60(15368) Clarified
1 point

Keyboard Warrior hate to upset you but Social Security is not doomed government will continue to take your earned money from you for Social Security. Don't doubt that fact !

Side: Sounds GOOD to me
Cartman(18192) Disputed
1 point

Why are you liberals always so proud of taking money from people through taxes?

Side: Sounds GOOD to me
outlaw60(15368) Clarified
1 point

I get it you want to show up on a social site and show you are intelligent but can you tell me who put Social Security in place and the name of that president and that president's party affiliation ?

Side: Sounds GOOD to me
Cartman(18192) Disputed
1 point

Why does it matter who started social security?

Side: Sounds GOOD to me
outlaw60(15368) Clarified
1 point

The College Grad thinks Social Security is a privatized alternative ? ? Say What ?

Side: Sounds GOOD to me
2 points

As always, Liberals want to steal from people who worked hard and were successful, and give to the irresponsible people who were lazy, irresponsible and non successful.

First of all, those Rich people whose SS taxes are only on a certain amount of their income, are only given the same money back based on that amount. They are getting back what they paid into the system. That is only fair to thinking people who are not socialist control fanatics.

If we went to flat tax system, that I have no problem with, you must now give back much more retirement money to Rich retirees based on what they paid into the system.

I'm sure this is not what you want.

The other poster was 100% correct when he said that Liberals destroyed the SS when they made it possible to use SS funds for other social programs. The lives of Democrats and the Left is spent taking as much money as possible from where ever they can take it to spend buying votes from those they pander to.

Our nation is indeed on the road to bankrupcy because politicians refuse to cut spending even on the rate of growth of programs. The Left is truly destroying this nation.

Side: It's a commie plot
1 point

EXCON you are a business person aren't you ? Flat taxes would not work for your employees ? Being you only pay 22% corporate tax because of a aggressive tax planner just think think if your business had a flat tax rate of 15% !39 minus 22 equals what 17 then your aggressive tax planner would have you paying 0 corporate tax LMMFAO !

Side: It's a commie plot