CreateDebate


Debate Info

29
34
Yes No
Debate Score:63
Arguments:32
Total Votes:79
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Yes (17)
 
 No (15)

Debate Creator

Hellno(17753) pic



Do you give money to the homeless?

Yes

Side Score: 29
VS.

No

Side Score: 34
4 points

If I have any, which is rare, I give them some.

But I won't do it if I see them smoking, I think the money goes to waste then.

Side: yes
2 points

Theres this one hobo in my town and he asked for money all day annd then he dosnt even use it for food and he just buys cigarrets all day and i think its a big wast but some of the homless will probablly use it for good

Side: yes
2 points

yeah ,, its important to check what they are doing of a money... so it is better to give them other types of aids rather than money......

Side: No
2 points

ur totally right ....................................although......................................homeless deserve money.....i gave one guy...he was aboriginal, and we saw were he went....with his mates and guess what....they were all smoking and drinking bottles and more bottles of ALCAHOL so im in doubt with them of course

Side: yes
2 points

well it doesnt have to be 5$ it can be 1$. remeber 1$ can help. "every little bit helps

Side: No
1 point

I don't have any delusion my pocket change is going to cure their schizophrenia or PTSS and they'll suddenly become sane and get a steady job,

but I figure if a beer gives them a moment of happiness in their otherwise miserable life, I'll contribute to the cause.

You are better off donating to established charities though, than giving your money to homeless you see on the street.

Side: yes
1 point

Yup, and I say "Here, go buy yourself a beer".

Side: yes
1 point

I love to know that i am doing a right thing for a stranger. You might not know what they do with the money, but it is a good thing. When ever me and my mom drive and whe see a homeless i always tell to give atleast a little bit of money she has left.

Side: yes
1 point

I tend to aid those at a disadvantage. Last homeless man I saw I gave $10.

Side: yes
1 point

yea i would give money to a hobo. I mean there are people in the world that are less fortunate than us. I don't think it is right to take advantage of things that we have.

Side: yes

Yes, I do every once in a while then they just kept sending me mail to send more money so I quit for a while.

Side: yes

I will do so but sometimes it is scary when someone comes up to you because you don't know if he is carrying a gun.

Side: Yes
0 points

Sometimes I give money, when I have it. Not all homeless people are in that situation because of drugs, a lot are people just like you or me. The last homeless man I gave a dollar to said he wanted to buy a grape soda. I watched him walk into the store, and what did he come out with? A grape soda. So not all are liars either. I think people who ignore the homeless are ignorant twits. Indifference is the greatest evil on this planet.

Side: yes
1 point

Also, another thing to take into consideration, a lot of homeless are mentally handicapped and are not able to work or find work, so telling them to get a job is ignorance. America shouldn't have homeless people, there should be more programs aimed at making sure all people here have homes.

Side: yes
Hellno(17753) Disputed
1 point

So, do you call all people that disagree with you "ignorant twits"? Sorry but just because some people don't think it's a good idea to give cash to the homeless doesn't make them ignorant twits....

Side: No
Liddy(36) Disputed
1 point

Of course it does, especially when you give your excuses. They may sound like reasonable excuses, but when you break it down, it's all ignorance. People like to view the homeless as lesser beings who are there because they are lazy, drug addicts, etc. What people fail to realize is that most people become homeless because of circumstances. The homeless are no different than you or I. One day you may be homeless, and maybe then you will realize why I think people like you are ignorant twits.

Side: yes

I give them the latest edition of the classifieds instead. That way they can find work. ;)

Side: No
1 point

Well they probably just use that to wipe their ass...............

Side: No
3 points

No, I don't because there are no homeless people around the area where I live. At least none that camp out on sidewalks and such. Only some strange looking hitch hikers occasionally. Shoot I need what money I have for me & my kid to get by.

Side: No
2 points

No doubt about that and you better stay away from those strange looking hitch hikers! LOL

Side: No
3 points

Lmao, believe me Hellno, I do!! I stay away from most everybody!

Side: No
2 points

No, I don't give them any money but I would give them some advice.....

Side: No
2 points

I don't usually give them money but i do give them food and I know every holiday I go around the streets and if there are any homeless people I feed them too.

I also give them cards with the information of the closest soup kitchen and shelter.

Rarely have I ever given a homeless person money unless I was on the subway and didn't have any food with me.

Side: No
2 points

Excellent, you are such a good person... that's exactly what we should do.

Side: No
2 points

Charity stops people from solving their own problems, give a man a sandwich bar and he will eat for a day, tell him to get off his * and do something...

Only exception is people are physically unable to solve their own problems such as disabled.

Side: No
1 point

If I had plenty of money, I might. But as it is, I can only spare so much money, so I make sure that what I do donate is worth it. I don't mind donating to charities like the Red Cross or the Cancer Society, because I can be pretty certain that they'll use the money for a good cause. But I'm a lot more reluctant to donate to homeless people because I don't know why they're homeless, how bad their situation is, and what they'll use the money for.

(And I'm not even talking about homeless people spending donated money on booze or drugs. The last time a homeless person asked me for money, it was some dude asking for $5 so he could buy a cappuccino. Jesus, I wouldn't spend $5 on a cappuccino for myself, let alone for a complete stranger. I can't help but think that if you're willing to buy an overpriced luxury item, either you're not poor at all, or you have disastrous spending habits and me giving you money would only be fueling this spending addiction.)

Side: No
1 point

no because your not doing them a favor.

Through my experience what the homless need is some love conversation and regonizing their existance for crying out loud. Second they need the word of God because it is very precious to the human sole. Third go buy them some food, or make some sandwithes at home with some cookies, and a drink. Third try your best not to bring your story in the conversation but ask them what their story is, and let them do the talking. Last advice if needed. Names are very important remeber their names. Bring forth Love that is found in you through JEsus christ.

Side: No
1 point

One more point, Giving money to the homless may attract unwanted attention, because beleive it or not word spreads around that your giving out money, and your name will be know. More homless may even come because of money your giving out.

Side: No