CreateDebate


Debate Info

15
9
No, there is always something Yes, we create existence
Debate Score:24
Arguments:18
Total Votes:25
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 No, there is always something (9)
 
 Yes, we create existence (8)

Debate Creator

ThinkerLad(267) pic



Does believing in something create its existence?

Let's take God. If, in the past, humans did not come up with the theory of God, would he/she therefore not exist, as they aren't part of our knowledge and we would have no way of knowing about him/her?

No, there is always something

Side Score: 15
VS.

Yes, we create existence

Side Score: 9
2 points

Believing in something is merely an endorsement of an idea. There is nothing to suggest that it creates anything of objective substance.

Side: No, there is always something
ThinkerLad(267) Disputed
1 point

Yes I am talking about existence in terms of a universal and ideological sense.

Side: Yes, we create existence
Jace(4530) Disputed
1 point

Universality cannot be accomplished by one person or even a lot of people believing in something; it must be common among all people to qualify, and arguably even independent of human conception.

Ideological existence is different from actual existence; that the idea of a thing exists does not mean that the thing represented by the idea exists itself. At most, believing in something creates that idea of its existence but not its actual existence.

Side: No, there is always something
1 point

If believing in something creates its existence then not believing in something should destroy its existence and when you see it that way around it's obviously false.

Side: No, there is always something
31337(560) Disputed
1 point

That could easily be countered by someone else believing in it's existence.

As long as someone believes it then it suits the criterion.

Believing that something is absent, isn't believing something, because it's believing that there is nothing there. Nothing can not be something.

Side: No, there is always something
instig8or(3310) Disputed
1 point

So what is empty space?

Side: Yes, we create existence
2 points

Naturally - just look at the world around us. It is so much a different place to the one that I grew up in post WWII

Our creative thoughts and imagination have produced everything we have made and use in our world today.

We now know far much more than we did in 1945, our technology and science have improved the lives of millions, all from the ideas of the minds of the people who created them

Side: Yes, we create existence

I will opine that nothing exists unless a brain is there to think of existence.

Side: Yes, we create existence
Cartman(18205) Disputed
3 points

Apparently you believe bacteria didn't exist before organisms with brains.

Side: No, there is always something
1 point

Whether real or a fanciful notion, to the believer it does.

Side: Yes, we create existence