CreateDebate


Debate Info

6
6
Yes end labeling No keep labeling
Debate Score:12
Arguments:14
Total Votes:12
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Yes end labeling (6)
 
 No keep labeling (6)

Debate Creator

-Yuri-(284) pic



End labeling on create debate

This site is called Create Debate hence we should all be creating debate. Debate is taught as seeking the truth of a conflict which side is correct or more correct then the other side.
Labeling someone is calling someone a name which bases what they believe of that name aka a label so for example calling someone a liberal or progressive or all those political names.

My point which is the center of this debate. Labeling proves nothing in terms of proving a point right or wrong unless said point is about said person. In a debate starting of saying things like "that is bullshit its such a progressive view" or "you liberals make me sick" or any of the other political things. Those statements do not prove anything they are to just start personal conflict which is not the point of debate. 


Yes end labeling

Side Score: 6
VS.

No keep labeling

Side Score: 6
1 point

You are absolutely correct. Identifying someone as, for example, a "Liberal" or "Conservative" fails to test the validity of their arguments.

But in a free speech activity you're never going to get labels to end.

Side: Yes end labeling
-Yuri-(284) Clarified
1 point

Indeed it would never end but hopefully show how illogical it is.

Side: Yes end labeling
1 point

My point which is the center of this debate. Labeling proves nothing in terms of proving a point right or wrong unless said point is about said person. In a debate starting of saying things like "that is bullshit its such a progressive view" or "you liberals make me sick" or any of the other political things. Those statements do not prove anything they are to just start personal conflict which is not the point of debate.

Side: Yes end labeling
1 point

Oh what the freak !!! .... you're nothing more than a de-labeler aren't you

Side: No keep labeling
1 point

This site is an oligarchy and the admins and mods support labeling being permitted. No one can defy them.

Side: No keep labeling
-Yuri-(284) Disputed
1 point

Do I care what the admin say? No I do not that is the point of debate we are here to debate things and I am saying that they offer nothing for a debate so should not be here. "also site your sources if they said this show me"

Side: Yes end labeling
Simzy(57) Disputed
1 point

Their actions speak louder than words.

Side: No keep labeling

When someone has "liberal" as their political affilliation on their profile, to assume they have liberal beliefs is just common sense. Now make me a samich.

Side: No keep labeling
-Yuri-(284) Disputed
1 point

Please re-read my argument as you have not understood the point I am making. Has nothing to do with if someone is or not. It offers nothing for a debate and adds nothing proves nothing.

Side: Yes end labeling
1 point

Hello:

I'm a lefty.. Why on earth would I be pissed if someone called me a lefty, or a liberal or a left winger.. I'm ALL of those things.. Consequently, I don't believe labeling someone a right winger is rude IF he demonstrates right wing ideas.

None of those words are epithets. Call me an asshole or stupid, though and I'll be right back in your shit..

excon

Side: No keep labeling
-Yuri-(284) Disputed
1 point

Please re-read my arguement. Its not that it upsets me or whoever is called said label. Its that it does not hold and merit in proving something right or wrong

Side: Yes end labeling

Primarily, your opinion on it doesn't matter.

Also, the activity of labelling is hardly a problem.

Side: No keep labeling