CreateDebate


Debate Info

Debate Score:4
Arguments:6
Total Votes:4
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Forced $15 minimum wage on all business by a Big Brother Federal Government. Insane! (3)

Debate Creator

Cuaroc(8829) pic



Forced $15 minimum wage on all business by a Big Brother Federal Government. Insane!

No one is suppose to be able to raise a family on minimum wage. They are not meant for people with families!

If a person chooses to have kids, and chooses to stay at these entry level jobs, they will have a low income life. It's not rocket science. People will choose the standard of living they want.

It's a choice to have sex and get pregnant. If you choose to work minimum wage jobs, you better be choosing to use birth control and wait for children until you can afford them. If not, you have brought on your own problems in life!

If two people both working minimum wage jobs, do not have children, they can get by with a minimal lifestyle.

If people want more out of life, they will take jobs that require more physical labor,  more pressure, more abillities that make their service more vauable to the company and thereby pay more.

Many factory jobs require little ability to run assembly lines etc. but they pay more.
Digging ditches or other labor jobs require little schooling, etc. but they pay more.

Life is a choice to us all. It is the total opposite of freedom when a Big Brother Government forces higher pay rates across the board on companies that could possibly put them out of business and make it impossible to compete with other nations.

When Government forces business to pay more, whether it be healthcare or minimum wage, those costs will ALWAYS be passed on to the consumers which creates inflation and lowers everyone's quality of life.

After inflation, these same people who now make more from a higher minimum wage will pay more for food and the necessities of life, and will be in the same spot they were before the inflation.

Did you happen to notice what happened when Government made it easy for students to get college loans with low interest rates? What happened? Colleges charged more because they knew students would take out loans for high tuitions they could not afford.
That is why College tuitions costs so much. When you give people more free stuff, or wages beyond the work level, the market will raise the cost on everyone.

WAKE UP! The free market has proven to work and socialism has proven to not work!

Have you noticed what has happened to our welfare roles after eight long years of a closet Socialist Democrat administration? With every added social program, with every lowering of requirements to get free stuff, the welfare roles have grown and grown and grown.

When you make it easy for people to take the easy way out of life. THEY WILL!

What do you think will happen to those factory workers making $15 per hour, when they see entry level jobs with no pressure or special abilities paying the same?

They will demand more money for their skills and the cycle continues...INFLATION!

What do you suppose will happen to all the retired senior citizens who are living on a fixed income when it costs them so much more to go to fast food restaurants, or buy the simple necessities of life?
They will be hurt, not that this matters to selfish people only looking out for themselves.

As always, this is a Democrat Party who spend's it's life trying to buy votes by resdistributing everyone else's money.
-FromWithin
Add New Argument
1 point

Currently, the federal minimum wage is $7.25 per hour. At this rate, a single person working 40 hours a week for every week of the year without taking any sick leave or vacation time would have an income of around $13,000.00 after taxes. This is barely above the federal poverty guidelines for single persons ($11,880.00 before taxes). The federal poverty line also represents an average cost of living, which means it doesn't account for the higher cost of living in larger cities where educational and career opportunities concentrate. (For instance, the approximate cost of living in NYC for a year is closer to $13,000.00.) The current federal minimum wage can keep a single person out of poverty only so long as they have no calamities (such as unexpected medical), and it prevents them from responsibly taking out loans on things such as education, cars, and homes which are often essential to career advancement. This leaves a significant part of the domestic population financially insecure and immobile, which isn't ideal for any economy.

While I agree that it is negligent for people to have children before they have secured a financially stable position for themselves, the simple fact of the matter is that people will do this unless you want the federal government to try and stop them (which would be inconsistent with your anti-federalism). If it were just the parents that suffered from their financial irresponsibility, that would be one thing. However, the children did not ask to grow up malnourished or homeless and we know that having that sort of childhood is a significant causal variable in cycles of poverty. Try thinking about a higher minimum wage as less about the stupid parents, and more about the children and future economic stability of the nation.

(All that said, I would prefer it be resolved at a state level than the federal.)

Cuaroc(8829) Clarified
1 point

Except FromWithin only cares about children up until birth.

Lopilulu(286) Disputed
2 points

You are no saint.

You may say you care more than him but you do not know what he feels. FromWithin most likely had a very harsh upbringing and thinks that others were correct to never have shown him any empathy.

First understand psychology and politics becomes far easier to comprehend even when you totally disagree.

1 point

I would agree that "forcing" that $15 minimum wage is not the best thing to do. However, what led to this is the destruction of bargaining power in the individual companies. The $!5 is basically the same as it was when the minimum wage was installed, considering inflation and dollar value. If our Congress had allowed it to keep pace, if workers still had a voice, the "force" would not be necessary. Thirty years of stagnate wages, while CEO's etc. absorb money that the WORKERS produce to a level over 300% is "insane" also!

"Ye reap what ye sow". To have a great economy it MUST be somewhere near FAIR!