CreateDebate


Debate Info

13
17
Free Will No Free Will
Debate Score:30
Arguments:32
Total Votes:30
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Free Will (13)
 
 No Free Will (17)

Debate Creator

lolzors93(3225) pic



Free Will

For the debate's sake we are assuming that the God of the Bible is real.  Omniscience, omnipotence, and omnibenevolence are all up for debate.

Free Will

Side Score: 13
VS.

No Free Will

Side Score: 17
1 point

Their is such thing as free will that is why we can choose to believe whatever we want. God isn't going to force you to believe in Him its up to the person's choice if they want to make that decision or not.

We aren't God's puppets and all of the Christians weren't forced to believe in God but they made that choice.

Side: Free Will
AveSatanas(4443) Disputed
1 point

God forces tons of people to believe in him in the bible! He sends people to whipe out entire civilizations of nonbelievers! And if the church had its way, there would still be crusades to spread and convert everyone. And christians believe they are at the mercy of god and have to live this perfect life controled by their faith if they wanna get to "heaven" so they kinda are god's puppets. Theyre slaves to the religion which keeps them in with scare tactics and teachings to not think or ask questions.

Side: No Free Will
Srom(12206) Disputed
1 point

God forces tons of people to believe in him in the bible! He sends people to whipe out entire civilizations of nonbelievers!

No God doesn't force people to believe in Him and or the Bible. It is up to the person to decide if they want to follow God. I already addressed that but you weren't paying attention.

Are you talking about the Crusades that wiped out civilization of nonbelievers? Those weren't true Christians because true Christians wouldn't kill in the name of Jesus.

And christians believe they are at the mercy of god and have to live this perfect life controled by their faith if they wanna get to "heaven" so they kinda are god's puppets.

We try to live a perfect life even tho we can't because we have all sinned but everyday we try to live our best for God.

Theyre slaves to the religion which keeps them in with scare tactics and teachings to not think or ask questions.

Christianity is not a religion its a relationship with Jesus Christ. Religion is man's way to get to God and Christianity is God's way to get to man.

Christians don't use scare tactics to convert people they tell them about Jesus and how He loves and saves people from whatever sin they committed.

Side: Free Will
bham(10) Disputed
1 point

I think God gives choices between choosing to believe in him and do what he requests or choosing to do otherwise. Within these two choices he adds on the consequences; follow him and we go to heaven and be happy or defy him and go to hell. Now it is our choice and our free will to choose between consequences.

One can say it is stupid to choose to go to hell. But this really is only valid if one believes that what God promises us will happen is true- his promises of heaven and hell could just be words not a fact. If one decides to not believe in God, then the person won't believe in words of God hence the concept of heaven and hell will not sway a person's action since it is not an obstacle. It is our free will to believe in heaven and hell and it is our free will to modify our behavior based our own beliefs.

Side: Free Will
bham(10) Disputed
1 point

I think God gives choices between choosing to believe in him and do what he requests or choosing to do otherwise. Within these two choices he adds on the consequences; follow him and we go to heaven and be happy or defy him and go to hell. Now it is our choice and our free will to choose between consequences.

One can say it is stupid to choose to go to hell. But this really is only valid if one believes that what God promises us will happen is true- his promises of heaven and hell could just be words not a fact. If one decides to not believe in God, then the person won't believe in words of God hence the concept of heaven and hell will not sway a person's action since it is not an obstacle. It is our free will to believe in heaven and hell and it is our free will to modify our behavior based our own beliefs.

Side: Free Will
thedebater83(4) Disputed
1 point

I disagree people choose to believe in the bible and God and any other religion or god because they want to and the do what that religion ask of them because they want to and the believe it’s true or will benefit them

(Beleive in free will)

Side: Free Will
riahlize(1573) Disputed
1 point

Can you mess with with God? Screw up or change his plan for you in some way?

As for the rest, God gave us an ultimatum. Believe in him and his son before you die or go to hell. That's coercion. That's force.

Side: No Free Will
bham(10) Disputed
1 point

His coercion is based on invoking fear within a person. That can be changed easily if a person can recognize the fear and find a way to reduce the fear and anxiety. It is US who choose to follow and react to the fear. The decision may be unconscious if a person can't recognize or understand the fear but still, our reaction to fear is derived from us and our own mind- not by God.

Side: Free Will
Coldfire(1014) Disputed
1 point

The very fact that you were born by no choice of your own, and that every choice you made since then relies on that one involuntary event negates any 'free-will' you may think you have.

Your challenge, if you choose to accept it: If you consider the Bible truth, find anywhere in the Bible where it says we have free will or even implies that we do. The terms are that if you cannot find one justifiable piece of biblical evidence to support your position, you must either admit that the bible isn’t truth, or that you are wrong about free will. If you CAN find evidence to prove free will in the bible, I will gladly bow out of this debate.

Please take a fair warning that your selection of scripture will be thoroughly scrutinized to find relevance, context, and correct analysis of the text.

Here is one piece of evidence that I’m bringing to the table showing that the Bible doesn’t support the idea of free will:

Jeremiah 1:4-5 “4. The word of the LORD came to me, saying, 5. “Before I formed you in the womb I knew you, before you were born I set you apart; I appointed you as a prophet to the nations.”

To clarify, free will is not “making a choice,” choices are made regardless of which point of view in this debate is accepted. The concept of free will suggests that the choices humans make are not affected by outside conditions or causes. It’s an asinine and arrogant concept because it implies that humans are not subject to the relationship of cause and effect which encompasses everything in the known universe.

Side: No Free Will
Troy8(2433) Disputed
1 point

The concept of free will suggests that the choices humans make are not affected by outside conditions or causes.

I don't think this is a correct definition.

Side: Free Will
TimelordROOK(94) Disputed
1 point

Free will is a hoax. Theoretically speaking, it is possible to travel backward in time via wormhole. If you go back in time, you simply can not kill yourself, or alter the timeline in a way that would change the world you came from, because what you're doing already happened and quite obviously, you didn't kill yourself, or alter the timeline in any way. That means that there is a choice you simply can't make, invalidating free will.

Side: No Free Will
1 point

Determinism says that every action was decided at the beginning of the Universe, because there is only one possible manifestation of events. I do not believe that a truly self aware person's actions can be foretold. If people use logic and reason to make their decisions, then their emotions won't cause them to make repetitive irrational decisions. The only catch is that it takes years of philosophical inquiry to become truly self aware. Free will is an effective model, but that doesn't mean that it doesn't exist.

Side: Free Will
1 point

You can believe in whatever you want. Who is forcing you? There is no one in your mind but you.

Side: Free Will
1 point

There definitely is free will in the world since you are not forced to do anything, although opposition is a factor when doing just about anything.

My definition of free will is 'the ability and power to make our own decisions'. Unfortunately, things such as wars, poverty, and government corruption result from poor decisions being made by world leaders. This is the major reason as to why bad things happen in a world with an awesome, powerful god.

Side: Free Will
1 point

Yes because we as humans CHOOSE how to live our lives. We choose to do good, or we choose to do bad. We are responsible for are own actions.

Side: Free Will
TimelordROOK(94) Disputed
1 point

Good and bad are points of view relative to the observer.

to one, a man is a terrorist, to another he is a freedom fighter.

The only morality in this world is to put forward the fellow man.

When all men have a nurturing hand at their back, we all walk as equals, arm in arm.

Side: No Free Will

Do you even search recent activity? I posted a debate on this a few days ago

Side: No Free Will
lolzors93(3225) Disputed
1 point

I don't like joining in on debates that have already started so I don't search for any recent activity... haha

Side: Free Will
ricedaragh(2494) Clarified
3 points

Joining in on debates that have already started is what this site is about, creating debates similar to ones that are already open is kind of point whoring.

Side: Free Will

There's no such thing as a free lunch. Where there's a will, there are relatives.

I have no idea what that means. I just repeat the sound bytes ;)

Side: No Free Will

The bible says god plans our birth, life, and death. Because he plans every aspect of our lives this completely disproves free will. Because everything is predetermined. You may think you're choosing one or the other but no matter which you choose it have been predestined for you to pick a certain one. And how come God is so actively involved in humanity during the time of the bible, but not today? And if hes so "loving" and sees all that will happen, that means he let 9/11 happen, he lets kids starve around the world, he lets genocides happen, he lets all this evil happen and does nothing, yet in the bible theres a story where god helps Isaiah? issac? idk, some guy prove to all these Baal worshippers that he is the real lord by lighting a pyre with a sacrifice on it to prove hes real. In a time like this where theres so many more doubters, where is god to assert his dominance and show hes the lord? wheres his mighty fist?

Side: No Free Will
1 point

There is no evidence to suggest that there is any such thing as “free will” (1. Voluntary choice or decision. 2. Freedom of humans to make choices that are not determined by prior causes or by divine intervention. - Merriam-Webster Dictionary).

Whether or not we regard the biblical God as real in this debate is irrelevant. This may come as a big surprise even to most devout "Christians," but there is no scriptural evidence of such a thing anywhere in the bible. In fact there is more reason to believe the contrary according to scripture.

Side: No Free Will
1 point

Well, if God is omnipotent, then he must be omniscient. If he can't look into the future and know the future, he is not omnipotent.

With an omniscient God there can be no free will as God already knows what my future will be, what choices I will make etc etc - my life is already determined and the best I can have is an illusion of free will.

Though I have heard of an interesting solution that God gave up his omniscience and thus his omnipotence by creating free-willed beings whose actions are unknown to him. Take it with a grain of salt though.

In any case, it doesn't matter - free will cannot be possible anyway. In an omniscient theistic model, my future and choices are governed by God's knowledge of the future. In a non-theistic model, my future and choices are determined by the laws of physics. To deny this is to claim that my mind is somehow detatched from physical reality which is the object of physical laws.

An interesting question I would like to ask is - if time travel to the future is discovered, does this invalidate free-will? For me to go to the future, the future must first exist. If the future exists, then my individual future must also exist - therefore my future is already determined.

Side: No Free Will

the concept of time travel in a closed universe, that means without journeying to other universes, invalidates free will fundamentally.What happens, happens, because it always did happen and always will happen.

ALSO

if there is a such thing as free will, there can be no God, as He is omnipotent and by extension omniscient. He can only be both or neither. If he doesn't know how the future will unfold because his creations have free will and decide for themselves how the future will unfold, then He can not possibly be God.

Side: No Free Will
1 point

Just letting yall know what I think about this subject.... I don't believe that we have free will. The book has already been written but the characters don't know what is supposed to happen next.

P.S. I consider myself a Christian

Side: No Free Will
1 point

If there is an omniscient God, then we would all be doing exactly as it predicts. If it is omnipotent, then that means it has complete control over what we do. If it has a plan, then we must have to follow it. That is not free will. That is puppetry.

Side: No Free Will

No one asks to be born, therefore, there is no such thing as free will.

Side: No Free Will