CreateDebate


Debate Info

3
14
She's right She's wrong
Debate Score:17
Arguments:16
Total Votes:19
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 She's right (3)
 
 She's wrong (8)

Debate Creator

Amarel(5669) pic



Girl steals MAGA hat

She exemplifies the Culture of the campus left. Is current academia a force for good or a force for ill? Does your answer depend on whether you're a white supremacist?
https://youtu.be/c4GqU6KzLm4

She's right

Side Score: 3
VS.

She's wrong

Side Score: 14
Cocopops(347) Banned
1 point

This girl was simply conducting herself in the only manner she knows how.

Our black brothers and sisters feel they have special dispensation which allows them to ignore, and indeed flout the law, proudly commit acts of criminality and tell your white victims to go and fcuk themselves.

Why shouldn't they?

This is how these poor under privileged repressed African Americans are reared so they cannot recognise that their criminal activities are wrong.

Side: She's right
Amarel(5669) Clarified
1 point

I don't suppose you can back up your assertion with facts...

Also, she's not black.

Side: She's right
Cocopops(347) Clarified Banned
1 point

Well, she sure isn't a white lassie from Tallahassee.

There's definitely a touch of the 'tar brush' in there somewhere.

Side: She's right
1 point

Hello A:

I didn't watch the video.. Frankly, I think those hats ought to be stolen, shit in, and returned to their rightful owner..

excon

Side: She's right
Amarel(5669) Disputed
1 point

As she said in the video, "fuck your laws!". Am I right?

Use force against others and their property, dont bitch about it used in return.

Side: She's wrong
excon(18260) Disputed
1 point

Hello again, A:

It's called civil DISOBEDIENCE for a reason. Nobody is looking for a free lunch here.. You have a RIGHT to say what you want, but you're NOT immune to the consequences for what you said..

Same with protest.. People have a RIGHT to do it, but they're NOT immune to the consequences. People KNOW they'll be dragged out of a Senate hearing.. Apparently, protesting is MORE important.. People KNOW they can lose their jobs.. I guess their country is more important.. People KNOW that a car can run them over if they lay down in the street. People KNOW the dogs will be set loose on them if they cross the Edmund Pettus bridge, but they did it anyway.

And, I will be FOREVER in their debt.

excon

Side: She's right
Antrim(1287) Banned
3 points

The Make America Great Again is a very simple message which all Americans should support.

Unless that is they would prefer to see America decline to a level with which the Bongo feels comfortable, i.e, openly stealing other people's property, rioting, looting and drug dealing.

Due to the seemingly rehearsed nature of this charade I would suspect that it was no more than a well practised piece of anti-Trump propaganda.

Side: She's wrong
3 points

It is, in my interpretation of the video, most peculiar that someone would commit a crime and feel comfortable, if not boastful about being recorded in the act.

The apparent victim seems suspiciously passive about having his property stolen and appears to be concentrating more on his role playing part and not screwing up his lines than he is in getting his hat back.

There is no doubt that this is yet another transparent amateur production of, let's knock Trump, release.

M.G.M., eat your hearts out.

Side: She's wrong
1 point

As we can see, spreading hyperbolic rhetoric has real world consequences. The rhetoric infuses people with anger and resentment which of course manifests in violence and other criminal acts, like this one.

The worst part about it is that they have identified themselves as righteous and the other group as evil, thus excusing themselves of moral responsibility for their deeds. When this happens people are capable of the worst atrocities.

Side: She's wrong
1 point

This video show the assault that preceded the theft. I would happily press charges.

https://youtu.be/qLuGQ2rH9yE

Side: She's wrong
Kalamazoo(333) Clarified
2 points

Are you saying you were the victim and the video was taken by you?

Side: She's right
Amarel(5669) Clarified
1 point

No, I'm not a Trump supporter. I'm saying that if I were in his place, I would happily press charges.

Side: She's right
1 point

She is wrong to steal someone else's property and/or assault them.

It is not wrong to exercise your freedom of speech. But it is wrong if in order to do so you step all over someone else's rights.

But by the way, I think Trump has done the exact opposite of "Make America Great Again."

Side: She's wrong

Instead of Make America Great Again it shoul be Make Amarel Go Away

Side: She's wrong