CreateDebate


Debate Info

29
29
Oh God Yes! You are! No you're not asshole!
Debate Score:58
Arguments:41
Total Votes:68
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Oh God Yes! You are! (17)
 
 No you're not asshole! (22)

Debate Creator

Hellno(17753) pic



Hi! My Name is Hellno And I'm a Christian!

Am I a Christian just by saying so?

I've seen "Christian" after "Christian" accuse each other on here of not really being Christian!

What say you?

Oh God Yes! You are!

Side Score: 29
VS.

No you're not asshole!

Side Score: 29
2 points

Hell in the land of Christianity, anything goes. I'm sure there's even room for you too Hellno!

Side: Oh God Yes! You are!
3 points

Nope. Well, I can claim to be a bird, but that's completely irrelevant to whether I am.

Side: No you're not asshole!
1 point

Not exactly the same... a bird can't post on the Internet as far as know, but as an atheist I can claim to be christian when obviously I'm not.

Side: No you're not asshole!
2 points

I'm not denying either. I'm denying that you can be a Christian by "saying so".

Side: No you're not asshole!
2 points

I believe in giving people the benefit of the doubt, but you have not provided any reasonable proof that you are in fact a Christian. Your description says simply "because I am" it says nothing about the ideology.

Side: No you're not asshole!
2 points

They are usually saying that Sitara isn't a Christian.

I think what it comes down to is what defines a Christian. It is stupid to say that you can't be a Christian if you don't believe that abortion is wrong for example. But for example, if they don't believe in Christ, they are not a Christian. Sitara continuously says she doubts whether God exists or not. I think its legitimate to say she is not a Christian.

Side: No you're not asshole!
1 point

Well, I have no reason to doubt your beliefs. I guess in this instance you would have to prove you are a Christian.

Side: No you're not asshole!
1 point

Nope! I'm just an asshole.

Side: No you're not asshole!
1 point

Well, I have no problem with that. I haven't been affected by you at all. Unless you are speaking of your life outside of this site.

Side: No you're not asshole!

I guess it all goes back to the no true Scotsman fallacy and whether God alone is judge or not.

Side: No you're not asshole!
ProLogos(2793) Disputed
1 point

What substance do the Swedish have in this matter?

Side: Oh God Yes! You are!
0 points

You are off topic. This debate is about religion, not Sweden. .

Side: No you're not asshole!