CreateDebate


Debate Info

Debate Score:50
Arguments:30
Total Votes:53
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Hitler and Marx both Hated Jewry - Ironic? (28)

Debate Creator

Slavedevice(1393) pic



Hitler and Marx both Hated Jewry - Ironic?

They both said Jewry propelled the ravages of unbridled capitalism.  Marx was ashamed of his Jewish heritage.  Hitler had Jew ancestry as well.  So it’s not a genetic hate.  It’s a hate of actions.
Add New Argument
1 point

Hitler and Marx both Hated Jewry - Ironic?

Hello S:

Ironic?? Nahhh…. At one time or another, we've been hated by EVERYBODY...

It’s a hate of actions.

Look.. You HATE us because of our "actions".. Others HATE us because of our "success". Still others HATE us because of our "longevity". Then again, people HATE us because we're Gods chosen people..

I dunno WHY people HATE us, and I don't care.. I'm a Jewish warrior. People like ME are the reason we have survived and thrived... Chew on that.

excon

1 point

ironic?? Nahhh…. At one time or another, we've been hated by EVERYBODY...

It's Democrats and Muslims now.

excon(18261) Disputed
1 point

It's Democrats and Muslims now

Hello again, bront:

Nahhh… Liberal Democrats don't support Netanyahu, but that's got nothing to do with hating Jews... Is that what FOX is telling you???? DUDE!

excon

outlaw60(15368) Disputed
1 point

Well spoken by a CONFUSED idiot that does not know if it's a JEW or an ATHEIST !!

A JEWISH ATHEIST WARRIOR speaks ROTFFLMMFAO !!!!!!!

Your STATE OF CONFUSION is comical !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Floxu(55) Disputed
1 point

At one time or another, we've been hated by EVERYBODY...

I do agree Jews have been hated my many, but who hasn't been hated on? Mostly every religion, nation, ethnic group, and ideology has been hated. That's just how the world is. There will always be people who hate or dislike certain stuff.

Many people in China see Jews as the greatest ethnic group because of how the Jewish ethnic group have endured so many horrific, and destructive events, and still survived, just like themselves. Today Scandinavia, most of Europe respects Jews (however Norway did ban you for some time, the people didn't despise the Jews, but simply feared them.) I do agree Jews have been hated my many, but which nationality/religion/ideology hasn't been disliked, or utterly despised? The likely answer is not many.

You HATE us because of our "actions".. Others HATE us because of our "success". Still others HATE us because of our "longevity". Then again, people HATE us because we're Gods chosen people..

People hate for various reasons, yes, you're right on that. Some people are too prejudiced, though others may have had a bad experience with multiple people within a certain group which may make the person fear that group.

That Jews are Gods chosen people I won't argue much with, since I'm not a religious person myself. However, if Jews are God's chosen people, then what are Muslims and Christians? They believe in God too. They maybe pray to him another way, but why aren't they also God's chosen people? I would be very pleased to read your opinion on that.

I dunno WHY people HATE us, and I don't care..

Fine by me. I can't force you to care about something you wouldn't like to hear about.

I'm a Jewish warrior. People like ME are the reason we have survived and thrived... Chew on that.

It's great that people defend their own religion/nationality, I respect that. You're also right that people that fought for their homeland, or religion are the reason these various nations and religions have survived through the centuries, and even decades. Though your end phrase: "Chew on that." sounded kind of impolite. But that's just my mind thinking such.

excon(18261) Clarified
1 point

but why aren't they also God's chosen people? I would be very pleased to read your opinion on that.

Hello again, Flo:

Somewhere in the Christian bible, it says that Jews are God's chosen people.. It's not ME saying that.. I don't BELIEVE in the bible, but the haters do, and that really pisses them off..

excon

It's a German thing.*

1 point

It is important to point out he anti-capitalism of Nazis and Fascists when discussing the nature of the American Right.

1 point

It is important to point out he anti-capitalism of Nazis and Fascists

Wtf? Jesus Christ you are such an astonishing liar. The Nazis were anti-Communists. They embraced capitalism. At least they embraced their own version of it.

Just prior to the war, reports started to leak out concerning the Nazi's shift towards a centrally-coordinated capitalist economy, in which "Aryanization" and confiscation of Jewish-owned business played a large role.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/EconomyofNaziGermany#PoliticaleconomyofNazi_Germany

5 points

YOUR LINK:

Joseph Goebbels remarked about the merits of Hitler’s welfare state in a 1944 editorial “Our Socialism,” where he professed: “We and we alone [the Nazis] have the best social welfare measures. Everything is done for the nation

5 points

YOUR LINK:

Albert Speer in his memoirs remarked that “a kind of state socialism seemed to be gaining more and more ground” among many Nazi party functionaries, warning that Germany’s industry was becoming “the framework for a state-socialist economic order.

5 points

YOUR LINK:

Furthermore, under Nazi “Germany the official unions have been made compulsory by law”, forcing every worker to join Hitler’s state-owned labor union.

1 point

YOUR LINK:

Early in his political career, Adolf Hitler regarded economic issues as relatively unimportant. In 1922, Hitler stated that "world history teaches us that no person has become great through its economy but that a person can very well perish thereby", and later concluded that "the economy is something of secondary importance".[10] Hitler and the National Socialists held a very strong idealist conception of history, which held that human events are guided by small numbers of exceptional individuals following a higher ideal. They believed that all economic concerns, being purely material, were unworthy of their consideration. Hitler went as far as to blame all previous German governments since Bismarck of having "subjugated the nation to materialism"

1 point

YOUR LINK:

For these reasons, the Nazis never had a clearly defined economic programme.[original research?][citation needed] The original "Twenty-Five Point Programme" of the party, adopted in 1920, listed several economic demands (including "the abolition of all incomes unearned by work," "the ruthless confiscation of all war profits," "the nationalization of all businesses which have been formed into corporations," "profit-sharing in large enterprises," "extensive development of insurance for old-age," and "land reform suitable to our national requirements.

1 point

YOUR LINK:

The Nazis came to power in the midst of Great Depression. The unemployment rate at that point in time was close to 30%.[28] Hitler appointed Hjalmar Schacht, a former member of the German DEMOCRATIC PARTY, as President of the Reichsbank in 1933 and Minister of Economics in 1934

1 point

YOUR LINK:

Hitler also spent large amounts of state revenues for a comprehensive social welfare system to combat the ill effects of the Great Depression, promising repeatedly throughout his regime the “creation of a SOCIALLY JUST state.”[32] Hitler both expanded the state-owned welfare organizations[33] and privatized social welfare organizations

1 point

YOUR LINK:

One of the NSV branches, the Office of Institutional and Special Welfare, was responsible “for travellers’ aid at railway stations; relief for ex-convicts; ‘support’ for re-migrants from abroad; alcoholics; and the fight against illicit drugs and epidemics.”[39][40][41] The Office of Youth Relief, which had 30,000 branches offices by 1941, took the job of supervising “social workers, corrective training, mediation assistance,” and dealing with judicial authorities to prevent juvenile delinquency.[42] It is estimated that in the mid-1930s, German workers paid 15-35% of their income to taxes, SOCIAL PROGRAMS, and (due to government pressure) charities

Amarel(5669) Disputed
1 point

I was referring specifically to what the Nationalist Socialist included in the description of this debate.

centrally-coordinated capitalist economy

This is a contradiction in terms.

I was referring specifically to what the Nationalist Socialist included in the description of this debate.

in which "Aryanization" and confiscation of Jewish-owned business played a large role.

And this is antithetical to Capitalism.

1 point

YOUR LINK:

Nonetheless, Hitler was “an enemy of free-market economics”[50] whose regime was committed to an economic "New Order" controlled by the "Party through a bureaucratic apparatus staffed by technical experts and dominated by political interests," similar to the economic planning of the Soviet Union.

Amarel(5669) Disputed
1 point

Anti-communist is not the same as pro-capitalist. The bloods are anti-crips. That doesn’t make them pro-cops.

1 point

Hitler and Marx both Hated Jewry - Ironic?

Is that Jewelry ?????????????