CreateDebate


Debate Info

4
5
Yes to Wind Currents No to wind currents
Debate Score:9
Arguments:9
Total Votes:9
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Yes to Wind Currents (4)
 
 No to wind currents (5)

Debate Creator

Manzanillo(14) pic



Hokule'a - Worldwide Journey - Philosophical Chairs Debate

Central Statement: Wind currents were the largest contributor to the success of Hokulea's ability to traverse the globe. 

Yes to Wind Currents

Side Score: 4
VS.

No to wind currents

Side Score: 5
1 point

Wind is created from global winds which is a big contributor because it helps shift their boat and guide it. Wind current also affect the ocean current because without wind, little no ocean current to move the boat - Kuulei

Side: Yes to Wind Currents
1 point

Without wind, it would have a harder time moving in a timely manner. - Romy

Side: Yes to Wind Currents
1 point

I agree because without wind currents, the navigators can make decisions based on their observations on wind currents and wind currents move ocean currents. - Drake

Side: Yes to Wind Currents
1 point

I agree because wind helps people/navigators determine the weather and where they are heading to. - Kevin

Side: Yes to Wind Currents
1 point

Wind is not the only big contributor factors, there's also sun, star, sea, ocean current - Devin

Side: No to wind currents
1 point

The people itself can just be using the stars for help, the wind is extra. Nainoa says, " two key decisions - at sunrise and sunset - Sara

Side: No to wind currents
1 point

I disagree that the wind was the largest contributor of the Hokulea's Voyage. In other words, I think the voyager itself is the biggest contributor. - Ralph

Side: No to wind currents
1 point

I disagree with the central statement that wind is the main factor because I believe that it is more of a person's skills and knowledge along with weather, ocean currents, and temperature -John

Side: No to wind currents
1 point

I disagree with this statement because the Hokule'a required much more than wind currents to traverse the globe. The navigators relied on the stars as a way to find their direction. History shows that the Polynesians found their way to Hawaii by using many navigational tools and not the wind currents - Ethan

Side: No to wind currents