CreateDebate


Debate Info

Debate Score:11
Arguments:15
Total Votes:11
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 How do you explain the world if you don't believe in a higher power(God)? (11)

Debate Creator

Merlyn0(48) pic



How do you explain the world if you don't believe in a higher power(God)?

I don't want to insult anyone's opinion, I am just curious.
Add New Argument
1 point

within man are the seeds of his own destruction .......... so far so good ? .. so far so good ? .. so far so good ? .. SPLAT !!!!

----------------------------------------------

.................. http://dadmansabode.com/

Merlyn0(48) Clarified
1 point

Ummm.... I don't really see how that answers my question, but okay.

1 point

He sort of believes in a higher power. He can't actually answer the question.

1 point

There are alternative, spiritual, explanation that doesn't involve a God. ;)

1 point

That's rather broad; it would help considerably to know what you mean by "the world". Is there something more specific that you're interested in? Like... existence, ethics, meaning, etc.... what're we after?

Merlyn0(48) Clarified
3 points

Yeah sorry, I realize that might be a bit unspecific. How do you find meaning? if everything, according to evolution is just a random chain of events, and you are just another chain in these events why does it matter that you exist

NowASaint(1380) Clarified
1 point

None of these fools could answer your question because it doesn't matter if they exist if God does not value them.

NowASaint(1380) Clarified
1 point

You need to ask this question again......they all went silent the first time, maybe they missed it

1 point

Thanks for clarifying.

I don't find meaning and I don't believe my existence matters, and I'm alright with that. It's not something I find to be missing from my life, and I honestly think it would be stressful believing that one's life had a significance that one had to live up to. I have interests and desires and those are sufficient for me. It doesn't bother me that it's all determined and beyond my control, either; I can still enjoy the ride.

I wouldn't say I'm typical of most atheists, though. I think a lot of them tend to find subjective significance in their own ways, and the objective meaning God is believed to provide by theists isn't really necessary for that. I can't speculate to much more about that, though.

1 point

If you ask that question to any other life form on earth - a tree, amoeba, squirrel, dolphin - you'll get no answer, but they'll go on happily living and doing what they do. What's wrong with that?

Hey, why isn't the dolphin obsessed with what it must do to live eternally after death? Why doesn't it think life is meaningless without a higher power?

Why?

Because it's smarter than most humans, that's why.

1 point

But why would we or should we have to explain the world , and explain it to who ?

If I claim for me the world was made by pink unicorns and that explains it to me well that's that isn't it ?

1 point

The world ------- Hmmmm

This planet was formed by gravity.

Next question.

Which part of the world?

Perception, matter, causation or everything?

Because I don't use an overly simplified approach to combine it all and say "God".

1 point

indeed ..... ignorance in the byproduct of unbelief ...... where we were / where we are / where we are headed

Why would a "higher power" be required to begin with?

------------------------------------------------------------