CreateDebate


Debate Info

5
3
Anarcho-communist Anarcho-capitalist
Debate Score:8
Arguments:4
Total Votes:8
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Anarcho-communist (2)
 
 Anarcho-capitalist (2)

Debate Creator

Elvira(3446) pic



How would you like your anarchy?

Anarcho-communist

Side Score: 5
VS.

Anarcho-capitalist

Side Score: 3

How would you like your anarchy?

I prefer mine non-existent.

However, Anarcho-communist seems to be a more accurate term since Anarchic utopia is the supposed end goal of the communists.

Anarcho-capitalism is a contradiction in terms since capitalism requires protection of property rights through enforceable law.

Side: Anarcho-communist
2 points

Not true anarchy if people still need to climb up the ladder. No, if I were to have true anarchy, then we would be animals. Burn down the hierarchies!

Side: Anarcho-communist
2 points

While capitalism does require a state to recognize private property, I suppose the point anarcho-capitalists are trying to make is that property doesn't need a state for recognition.

Since under anarcho communism we'd have high-end restaurants being managed by uneducated students and part-timers, no money or pricing to indicate supply or demand, I can't imagine living under anarcho communism being very pleasant.

Side: Anarcho-capitalist
1 point

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

I'd say mutualist if anything, but I'd gladly take anarcho capitalism over anarcho communism.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Side: Anarcho-capitalist