CreateDebate


Debate Info

7
10
Very No...
Debate Score:17
Arguments:17
Total Votes:17
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Very (7)
 
 No... (10)

Debate Creator

chatturgha(1631) pic



I'm Creating Around 250 'Magic: The Gathering' Cards From Home. Am I Nutz?

Magic: The Gathering: http://www.wizards.com/magic/magazine/default.aspx

No. I'm not making or planning on making money off of it. It's for fun.

Yes. I'm getting consultants to make sure all the cards are balanced. I'm not stupid.

No. I own none of the artwork, settings, nor the game Magic the Gathering. But I own the card designs.

Yes. That means I cannot draw or think up my own original setting. You and your insults may kindly take a hike.

 

I now question my sanity. The answer is in your hands: Am I nutz for doing this?

EDIT - Here's a preview: (Working on it...)

I do not own the artwork, Warcarft universe, nor the game Magic: The Gathering. Blizzard Entertainment owns Warcraft and the artwork. Wizards of the Coast own Magic: The Gathering.

But the card DESIGN dubbed 'Azure Watch Vindicator' is copywrite chatturgha via www.CreateDebate.com

Very

Side Score: 7
VS.

No...

Side Score: 10
1 point

Sure are nuts! Who in their right mind gives a damn about "Magic: The Gathering"? Cards? Really? I used to collect baseball cards, but "Magic: The Gathering" cards? Give me a break.

Side: Very
chatturgha(1631) Disputed
1 point

Grown nerds give a damn about Magic: The Gathering, that's who. And a fair amount of parents with teenage children.

It's been running for more then 10 years successfully.

My question to you now is: Can you play a card game with baseball cards? You can with MtG

Side: No...
1 point

I'm going with nuts because I have no idea what in the hell this is... And I fear the unknown! LOL

Side: Very
1 point

And I fear the unknown!

Actually that was just a joke... I thought I better clarify in case Garry sees this and tries to twist it into something and use it against me some time.

Side: Very
chatturgha(1631) Disputed
1 point

Ha ha, I don't think Garry necessarily cares about trying to damage you. Then again, now he might... xD

Side: No...
chatturgha(1631) Disputed
1 point

I put a Magic: The Gathering link at the top.

No longer must it be unknown! No longer must you fear it! ;D

Side: No...
1 point

No you are not nuts because there is a game on the PS3 that I play and its quite fun I would say.

Side: No...
chatturgha(1631) Disputed
1 point

Yes, but I'm actually creating and balancing the cards. Without a budget. With the help of just a few friends.

In the MtG videogames, all they did was take cards they had already made in between 10 and 2 years ago and put them into the game.

Are you sure I'm not nutty?

Side: Very
Srom(12206) Disputed
1 point

No your not nutty I myself play the card game too. It is quite fun and addicting sometimes.

Side: No...

I personally hate that particular card game, but if you can pull off your little 'experiment' of sorts I would still have quite a bit of respect for you. Do what makes you happy mate :)

Side: No...
chatturgha(1631) Disputed
1 point

Daaw, why hate it? :3

Side: Very
1 point

phphphph no your not nutzz and trust me i know alot about beeing nutz! i find that rather interesting i personally like that card game it really is addictive :3 adoy!! 0.o

Side: No...
1 point

There's nothing wrong with having a hobby! As long as you're not trying to make money off of them I don't see anything wrong with yours.

Side: No...