CreateDebate


Debate Info

25
41
NO, I shouldn't Yes.. They're INNOCENT
Debate Score:66
Arguments:65
Total Votes:75
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 NO, I shouldn't (23)
 
 Yes.. They're INNOCENT (27)

Debate Creator

excon(18261) pic



I'm a Jew. Should I forgive modern day Nazis because they personally didn't kill Jews?

NO, I shouldn't

Side Score: 25
VS.

Yes.. They're INNOCENT

Side Score: 41
2 points

Their hate is fresh and directed against you. Fresh hate deserves a fresh response. That does't justify you becoming violent, but it does if it reaches the point you have to save your lives now.

Side: NO, I shouldn't
1 point

NOBODY should forgive Nazi's for ANYTHING, they are hate filled scum and shouldn't share the air we breath ... either todays or earlier.

Side: NO, I shouldn't
cruzaders(325) Disputed
1 point

I am not supporting nazies ( I am french and I too have a bone to pick with them) but do you know why germans hated jews even before Hitler rose to power in 1933? Because the jewish banks stopped helping germany after the english promised them to give them back their land in 1918.And thats why the germans had to ask for peace , and they were humiliated by the treaty of Versailles . Thats where their grudge against jewish people come from

Side: Yes.. They're INNOCENT
Quantumhead(749) Disputed
-1 points

NOBODY should forgive Nazi's for ANYTHING, they are hate filled scum and shouldn't share the air we breath ... either todays or earlier.

NOBODY should forgive Jews for ANYTHING, they are hate filled scum and shouldn't share the air we breath ... either todays or earlier.

(Just because I'm in the mood to troll).

Side: Yes.. They're INNOCENT
AlofRI(3294) Clarified
2 points

I thought you were a reasonably intelligent human being, .... sorry for the misunderstanding.

Side: NO, I shouldn't

OK just because they didn't kill anyone doesn't mean their believes aren't pure. My point being ask your self if it was during the Holocaust would they be the ones killing people. I would say no you shouldn't but I also think it mostly depended on the person and how far they go for their believes.

Side: NO, I shouldn't
1 point

A modern day Nazi is just so, a Nazi. By defining yourself as a Nazi, you are accepting and agreeing with the “Nazi culture” which is based upon a strong hatred of Jewish people and the idea that Jewish people should die. It doesn’t matter when you existed, a Nazi is a Nazi. If you are still struggling with the idea that because a Nazi hasn’t killed someone, they deserve mercy and forgiveness, let me put it into perspective. As an American Citizen, would you feel inclined to forgive a current member of ISIS because they haven’t killed anyone even though their predecessors have killed thousands? Being a Nazi comes with ideas and theories that must be upheld (i.e. Jewish people are animals that deserve nothing more than death). Now if we are talking about forgiving GERMAN people, that is a different debate. To conclude, the dictionary defines a Nazi as a person with extreme racist or authoritarian views. A Nazi now is the same as a Nazi 50 years ago. Just because they exist later in time doesn’t exempt them from the horrors their predecessors committed upon the Jewish community.

Side: NO, I shouldn't
5 points

Yes you say you are a JEW ! How many times do you need to repeat IT STUPID ?????????

Side: Yes.. They're INNOCENT
Antrim(1287) Clarified
4 points

Having convinced some of the more gullible participants on the site of his ethnic background, he's now trying to convince himself of his Jewish origin.

You've picked up very well on the suspicious repetitiveness of his dubious, if not downright fictitious claims of being Jewish.

As a black man, what he's trying to do in these posts is to draw parallels with the Nazi's treatment of Jews with the alleged sins of our fathers towards the blacks.

Like all Walter Mitty characters he has overdone his role playing and attracted the well founded misgivings of his 'silly boy' pretence.

Side: NO, I shouldn't
3 points

You nailed it Antrim the basement boy is downright fictitious.

Side: Yes.. They're INNOCENT
excon(18261) Disputed
1 point

Hello A:

I LOVE this.. I'm a "bongo" playing a fake Jew.. This is delicious.

excon

Side: NO, I shouldn't
3 points

Yes , I think you may have mentioned it once or twice ; why should you forgive them when you stated you hate them ?

You do seem rather confused whys that ?

Side: Yes.. They're INNOCENT
excon(18261) Disputed
0 points

Hello D:

The POINT of the post is that I SHOULDN'T forgive them BECAUSE I DO hate them.. Not confusing at all, if you speak English.

excon

Side: NO, I shouldn't
Dermot(5736) Disputed
1 point

Yes , you have admitted your hatred for them several times ; I am an English speaker and believe me everything you say is confusing , I doubt you're even a Jew .

Side: Yes.. They're INNOCENT

You can do what you want Con. Wll you forgive ANTIFA for going after Ben Shapiro, an open Jew? Probably not. He doesn't have the donkey patch. He's not in your club. It's not who you are with the Democrats right Con? It's what you are. And he's not in your club.

http://www.dailywire.com/sites/default/files/uploads/2016/05/20160225shapirocslasony-a6k207select.jpg

https://townhall.com/columnists/benshapiro/2010/04/28/an-open-letter-to-american-jews-n1311760

https://www.campusreform.org/?ID=9435

Side: Yes.. They're INNOCENT
1 point

None of your ancestors were ever killed by the Nazis. Why would they need your forgiveness?

Side: Yes.. They're INNOCENT