CreateDebate


Debate Info

25
32
men's restroom women's restroom
Debate Score:57
Arguments:60
Total Votes:60
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 men's restroom (14)
 
 women's restroom (24)

Debate Creator

dadman(1703) pic



I'm a lesbian trapped in a man's body .. which restroom ?

men's restroom

Side Score: 25
VS.

women's restroom

Side Score: 32
5 points

What is a Lezbian? Is that someone from some mythological land of Lezbia? Unless it's some bizarro world, I'd assume they'd use the men's room.

Side: men's restroom

Stop discussing shit you don't understand and please remove yourself from the gene pool.

Side: men's restroom
dadman(1703) Clarified
1 point

................................ please clarify / eloborate

Side: men's restroom
TheEccentric(3382) Clarified
3 points

You don't fucking understand who trans people are so don't even get into it. You are just a religitard who loves to judge and hate people for being different. I wouldn't expect you to be capable of understanding why a trans woman can be a lesbian.

Side: men's restroom
1 point

Yes yes*

Side: women's restroom
1 point

Yes yes*

Side: women's restroom

Discussing which restroom they should be using is a little premature; we should be discussing which mental health institution they should check in to or which psychologist they should be visiting for treatment and therapy.

Living in close proximity to San Francisco I come across more transgendered individuals than one might in other parts of the world, and while I don't hold any animosity towards them, I do wholeheartedly believe they are mentally ill.

People who identify as a gender other than the one defined by objective standards of gender, like chromosomes, hormones, and gentiles, constitute a tiny minority of any population. A minority so tiny it's actually comparable to the number of people who identify as a species other than human, despite all the contrary evidence that they are not, in fact, a horse or a cat or a dragon. There's not a shred of evidence any of these humans are anything but, despite their protests that they feel, "trapped in a human body," coincidentally the exact same protest transgenders make.

If you think that someone who really believes at the core of their being that they are actually a dog and not a human being, and that they want to act out that fantasy by wearing nothing but a collar, barking at things, walking on all fours, and eating kibble, is utterly insane, I agree with you. And I find a transgendered person wanting to take drugs to fuck up their body chemistry, saw off their body parts, and run around in a wig to be equally insane.

Generally I don't have any problem with people doing something crazy so long as it's not a danger to others or themselves. However, transgenders suffer some of the highest suicide rates in the country, before and after any surgery or hormone treatment they undergo. If you care about the quality of life for a transgendered person, then you must agree they need treatment, not to be coddled and told their condition is perfectly acceptable.

Side: men's restroom
1 point

Yes yes*

Side: women's restroom
1 point

Yes yes*

Side: women's restroom
1 point

All I can say is if I EVER hear of a man taking his dick out in the same room with my grand daughter is asking for one good ole fashion azz whoopn (wig and lipstick or not) .... kAAAPOW !!! SLAM / BASH !!!

Side: men's restroom
5 points

Very Christian of you. Jesus would be so proud.

Side: men's restroom
dadman(1703) Clarified
0 points

shoot ... you think I'm bad ?? ... just wait till God gets a hold of the pervert .. this is called the second death

Side: men's restroom
1 point

Also listen you idiot, trans women are not men. They are women so fuck off!!

Can you honestly look at this person and say she's a man? http://i.dailymail.co.uk/i/pix/2015/08/18/03/2B73735700000578-3201691-image-a-95_1439864931868.jpg

Side: women's restroom
1 point

Yes yes*

Side: men's restroom
1 point

A lesbian trapped in a man's body is another way of saying a man who likes to have sex with women. That's a heterosexual. You would use the men's room.

Either you made a brain teaser the others didn't get or you made a brain fart which fails to demonstrate the scenario you wanted to protest.

Side: men's restroom
Jace(5222) Clarified
1 point

A "lesbian trapped in a man's body" would actually be a transgender woman who likes other women since being a lesbian necessarily means being a woman (otherwise, semantically, the person in question would be a gay man). Among the many empirical errors evident in the original statement, the most relevant one here is the conflation of sexuality with gender. This is a fairly obvious case of ignorance- and prejudice-induced brain flatulence, and hardly a "brain teaser" for anyone with an even moderate grasp on queer semantics.

Side: men's restroom
1 point

Yes yes*

Side: women's restroom
dadman(1703) Disputed
0 points

But I "identify" as a Lesbian .. and I protested nothing ....

I simply stated my scenario and sought advice as to which restroom I should use

Side: women's restroom
Grenache(6053) Clarified
1 point

My answer is still accurate even if you simply "identify" as a lesbian.

Side: men's restroom

Why does it matter?

This "bathroom" controversy is entirely manufactured.

Side: women's restroom
2 points

IKR. People and their hangups. Need to get over themselves and their insecurities.

Side: women's restroom
1 point

Yes yes*

Side: men's restroom
2 points

Go into which ever bathroom in which you look like you belong.

If you're dressed up like a woman, go into the feminine restroom.

If you're dressed up like a man, go into the masculine restroom.

It is as simple as that.

Side: women's restroom
Jace(5222) Disputed
1 point

Not that simple, actually. I don't clearly present as either binary gender. I go into either restroom and I get weird looks, if not actually being told "you're in the wrong restroom". Nor does saying, go into whichever bathroom you most identify with solve the issue since I don't identify with either. Better approach is to stop proscribing a "should" at all, IMO.

Side: women's restroom

Very well said

Side: women's restroom
2 points

Any restroom with no religious markings over the door. If there is an American Flag over it, it SHOULD be Okay, but, I wish I could promise that. I can't .... conservatively.

Side: women's restroom
dadman(1703) Clarified
1 point

Any restroom with no religious markings over the door ??? ...

Is there a "religious" marking over the door ? ... what does it look like ?

Side: men's restroom
AlofRI(3294) Clarified
1 point

Many of the old ones had a crescent (1/4 moon, Muslims, I guess.....) I was trying to be as ridiculous as the new "laws".

Side: men's restroom

I think you should pee in two cups and have a man and a female bring them into their own gender associated rooms. Then they should pour them out.

Side: women's restroom
AlofRI(3294) Clarified
1 point

But....but...What if the man gets the woman's pee, or vice-versa.....HORRORS! We'll ALL be damned to HELL! :<)

Side: men's restroom