CreateDebate


Debate Info

5
15
It IS a tax Trump can do no wrong
Debate Score:20
Arguments:12
Total Votes:21
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 It IS a tax (5)
 
 Trump can do no wrong (7)

Debate Creator

excon(18261) pic



If a tariff on China causes me to pay 20% MORE for a refrigerator, is that a tax


It IS a tax

Side Score: 5
VS.

Trump can do no wrong

Side Score: 15
1 point

If it isn't a tax it certainly is a "tax break" cancellation.

Side: It IS a tax
1 point

Yes it's a tax. This whole trade war is going to be very hard on the working class. Just research what always happens as a result of a trade war and you'll see that it's never good for the working class.

I've felt for many years that something should be done about the trade imbalance and unfair trade practices of the Chinese but of course Trump is doing it all wrong. Instead of carefully measured actions he's throwing bombs. His worshipers love it of course but they're the ones who'll suffer the most for it.

It's not going to be good for us. Brace yourself for another round of Republican spiraling inflation.

The last big trade war helped bring on WW2.

Supporting Evidence: Trade war (www.cnbc.com)
Side: It IS a tax
outlaw60(15368) Disputed
1 point

Obama did what about the trade imbalance ???????????

Rusty must be WW3 is coming ROTFFLMMFAO !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Side: Trump can do no wrong
1 point

Trump has this country all lined up for a take down. His trade war will spike inflation just as the tax cuts for the working class expire and at the same time the HUGE PERMANENT tax cuts for the rich begin which means that the working class will then have to Pay The Fat Cats Share Of The Taxes FOREVER, shouldering an even greater share of the tax burden than we did before (which was already much more than we should have been paying) which will shrink our net earnings. At the same time SPIRALING INFLATION will drive up the cost of EVERYTHING. Fuel costs are rising at this very moment. Auto manufacturing jobs are going away, dairy farmers are selling out. Soybean farmers are beside themselves because now they've lost their biggest market. We're all set up for the GREATEST DEPRESSION IN HISTORY.

THANKS TRUMP and THANK YOU TRUMP WORSHIPERS FOR MAKING THIS DISASTER HAPPEN. IDIOTS!

Side: It IS a tax
outlaw60(15368) Disputed
1 point

Trump has this country all lined up for a take down. His trade war will spike inflation just as the tax cuts for the working class expire and at the same time the HUGE PERMANENT tax cuts for the rich begin which means that the working class will then have to Pay The Fat Cats Share Of The Taxes FOREVER, shouldering an even greater share of the tax burden than we did before (which was already much more than we should have been paying) which will shrink our net earnings. At the same time SPIRALING INFLATION will drive up the cost of EVERYTHING. Fuel costs are rising at this very moment. Auto manufacturing jobs are going away, dairy farmers are selling out. Soybean farmers are beside themselves because now they've lost their biggest market. We're all set up for the GREATEST DEPRESSION IN HISTORY.

THANKS TRUMP and THANK YOU TRUMP WORSHIPERS FOR MAKING THIS DISASTER HAPPEN. IDIOTS!

All said by a DUMMY that has zero proof of a 4 ALARM FIRE that it claims to be REAL

Side: Trump can do no wrong
outlaw60(15368) Disputed
1 point
Side: Trump can do no wrong
outlaw60(15368) Disputed
1 point

What do u know about the trade imbalance ? More than the POTUS ??? If so you should run for POTUS and put your brilliance to work for the American People !

Side: Trump can do no wrong
1 point

Well, a tariff is a tax on imports, and not one the president should have such authority over. When you pay more as a result of a tariff the cost of that tax is transferred to you, in much the same way other taxes not directed at consumers fall on them indirectly. If you don’t like it, remember it when it’s your favorite president taxing your favorite target in your name.

Side: It IS a tax

Buy a different refrigerator. Then go buy some soy beans.

Side: Trump can do no wrong
excon(18261) Disputed
1 point

Buy a different refrigerator

Hello bront:

I dunno.. What happened to the free market?? If a Chinese fridge is cheaper, why is Trump making is more expensive??

Is your adoration for Trump so great that you'll even support his TAX INCREASES?????? DUDE!

excon

Side: It IS a tax
5 points

If a Chinese fridge is cheaper, why is Trump making is more expensive??

Because as it stands now, we have a 340 billion dollar trade deficit with China annually. Bush and Obama should have taken care of that, but they left it to Trump to attempt to save us from bankruptcy. We could try doing nothing about it since trade wars don't feel good, but the nation will collapse. In reality, Bush and Obama most likely had no idea what to do. At least now we have a driver at the wheel on trade, rather than autopilote as we nose dive the plane towards the Earth.

As for his tarrifs on Europe, Mexico and Canada, I'm not a big fan, and get a bit uneasy, seeing they aren't blatantly cheating and stealing from us like China overtly does. But...if it works, I'll say welp. I don't argue with results simply because the journey wasn't simple.

Without a giant coalition of nations, they, the Chinese, have no chance of sustaining a trade war with us for long. Our GDP is double theirs, and they depend on us as customers way more than we depend on them in the grand scheme of things.

https://assets.weforum.org/editor/Dan3sZA28fAcUWSeizb3vYE5I9x4y0sPsUBIW0Ap1lI.jpg

What I know for certain is we cannot sustain these types of trade deficits to everyone and come out to the good for much longer.

Side: Trump can do no wrong