CreateDebate


Debate Info

23
27
They had cars in 2,000 BC Probably not
Debate Score:50
Arguments:44
Total Votes:58
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 They had cars in 2,000 BC (21)
 
 Probably not (23)

Debate Creator

CrapWeasel(529) pic



If ancient cities are under water, was it because of manmade climate change?

Incredible Underwater Ancient Cities That Will Blow Your Mind



    

They had cars in 2,000 BC

Side Score: 23
VS.

Probably not

Side Score: 27
1 point

If lightning strikes the ground frequently, was it because man invented electricity?

You see how your assumption is a fallacy? Or nah?

You are conflating two separate issues, while trying to imply the existence of the first disproves the existence of the second.

Side: They had cars in 2,000 BC
CrapWeasel(529) Disputed
2 points

If lightning strikes the ground frequently, was it because man invented electricity?

This in no way ties in logically to the question.

It's certainly true that man did not cause in any way, the oceans and seas rising and covering up cities from the past.

1)Man didn't create ancient climate change.

2)There was drastic climate change in ancient times.

3)There has been no drastic climate change anywhere near this scale in your lifetime.

4)What would constitute a "normal" climate or how a climate "should be"? If the Earth warms half a degree, does that make it less or more "correct"?

Side: Probably not
Hootie(922) Disputed
1 point

This in no way ties in logically to the question.

It ties into your question precisely, because it is another example of the exact same fallacy. I also explained why your question is a fallacy, so I'm not really interested in your generic wall of denial.

Side: They had cars in 2,000 BC
Hootie(922) Disputed
1 point

Man didn't create ancient climate change.

Nobody has ever suggested man created climate change, either ancient or modern. Hence, your statement is both a straw man argument and a red herring, in that it is a conclusion which -- while correct -- has no relevance. It is therefore simply a form of misdirection.

There was drastic climate change in ancient times.

There is a stack of scientific evidence that man is negatively affecting the climate in modern times. Hence, this statement is also a red herring fallacy.

There has been no drastic climate change anywhere near this scale in your lifetime.

Despite having your fallacy explained and exemplified, instead of revising it you appear to simply be trying to force it down my throat. There have been no surges of electricity as large or as dramatic as a lightning storm in my lifetime, but this does not prove electricity is not real. You are simply trying to forcibly conflate two non-related phenomena and pretend that the existence of the first disproves the existence of the second. It doesn't, so stfu.

Side: They had cars in 2,000 BC
Spuds(1083) Disputed
1 point

You didn't answer the question.

If ancient cities are under water, was it because of manmade climate change?

Side: Probably not
outlaw60(14928) Disputed
0 points

Is the CO2 level way to high for the green vegetation in your world ??????????

I am still breathing are you ????????

Side: Probably not
1 point

If ancient cities are under water, was it because of manmade climate change?

Hello Crappy:

It's a good question.. I'm gonna ask a scientist.. Who you gonna ask? Your pastor?

DUDE!

Bwa, ha ha ha ha ha ha.

excon

Side: Probably not
outlaw60(14928) Disputed
1 point

SUPER STUPID step up and say there was manmade centuries ago LMMFAO ! You IDIOTS are the most factless people known to man.

Side: They had cars in 2,000 BC
outlaw60(14928) Disputed
1 point

SUPER STUPID is the so called melting ice in Greenland raising the levels of the Pacific Ocean ????????? LMMFAO !!!!!!! SUPER STUPID is California under water yet?

Side: They had cars in 2,000 BC
outlaw60(14928) Disputed
1 point

https://www.weather.gov/okx/1938HurricaneHome

LMMFAO check with the scientist on the 1938 hurricane and tie it to manmade climate change

Side: They had cars in 2,000 BC
Bronto(2027) Disputed
1 point

It's a good question.. I'm gonna ask a scientist..

Sure ya are con. You're going to also ignore that the climate cycles to extreme cold and extreme hot naturally, in cycles, pre man, according to....scientists...

Side: They had cars in 2,000 BC
0 points

Most of them are due to land shifts or volcanic activity. Back then they knew the land was fertile but didn't know about tectonic plates, they weren't entirely aware of what caused volcano's nor did they realize that volcanic activity from a great distance could cause a tsunami.

Of course their ignorance in where to build doesn't have anything to do with man made climate change today. We still build in dangerous location but our actions and technology now contribute a great deal to the climate. Yes Earth has changed over time and will continue to do so but again, that doesn't mean we aren't adjusting it to our detriment as well.

Side: Probably not
outlaw60(14928) Disputed
1 point

You Precious Jewel has the high CO2 content in the atmosphere cut off your oxygen and that of your allergic hubby ?

Side: They had cars in 2,000 BC
outlaw60(14928) Disputed
1 point

Jewel are you saying the Leftist Elite should not burn fossil fuel all the while saying the common people are adding to the fake Climate Chaos issue ? What makes sense in the confused world you people exist in ?????????

Side: They had cars in 2,000 BC
outlaw60(14928) Disputed
1 point

https://www.weather.gov/okx/1938HurricaneHome

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/GreatGalvestonhurricane

Yes Earth has changed over time and will continue to do so but again, that doesn't mean we aren't adjusting it to our detriment as well.

Explain the links you Leftist Water Carrier ! Make your point you idiot !!!!!!!!!!!

Side: They had cars in 2,000 BC
outlaw60(14928) Disputed
1 point

Leftist are you saying that Leftist weren't entirely aware of what caused volcano's?

What a stupid statement you made Jewel !

Jewel are you aware how ignorant you Leftist really are ?

Side: They had cars in 2,000 BC
SpiritOfWank(49) Disputed
1 point

I'll make you tap dance with a banana up your ass while I fuck a jar of mayonaise. Then I will make you a sandwich with the mayonaise and you won't be able to tell because jizz looks like mayonaise.

Side: Probably not
Mint_tea(3993) Disputed
1 point

Leftist are you saying that Leftist weren't entirely aware of what caused volcano's?

Just about everything you say is as ridiculous as this statement. Honestly I rarely waste my time trying to debate with you anymore, God knows you never read or comprehend what's being said.

Side: Probably not