CreateDebate


Debate Info

1
0
Wrong So right
Debate Score:1
Arguments:1
Total Votes:1
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Wrong (1)

Debate Creator

LiberalApple(92) pic



If u adopt ur daughter then when shes grown do her is it wrong?

If you adopt a girl and raise her as your daughter, then she grows into a woman, is it wrong to have sex with her, seeing there is no blood relation?

Wrong

Side Score: 1
VS.

So right

Side Score: 0
1 point

Just like Woody Allen?

I can't say if it's right or wrong, but it would seem rather unusual or inappropriate. But again, doesn't mean it's wrong. The bigger question is what the local laws of your land says. Is that considered incest or only incest if it's blood related?

Reminds me of the movie The Ballad of Jack and Rose. There's both something understandable if a father loves his daughter in more ways than one, because I think most of us would be lying to ourselves that at some point a father does develop some of these feelings. Most just learn to obviously not act on them and carry it on beyond their thoughts. But I can understand that as a man, you can develop feelings/attraction/whatever you want to call it to almost anyone! It just doesn't mean we're going to actually act on it. For a brief a moment, men can be attracted to their daughters, their sons, their sisters, brothers, male friends etc.... it's not really unusual. Certain familiar aspects of that someone may remind you of something that you love and become attracted to. I've often thought that if I were meet my myself in the female version, I'd be attracted to myself.....doesn't mean I'd want to marry myself or myself...but I can understand how one could develop an attachment or an attraction for even your own daughter.

Side: Wrong
No arguments found. Add one!