CreateDebate is a social debate community built around ideas, discussion and democracy.
If this is your first time checking out a debate, here are some quick tips to help get you started:
Arguments with the highest score are displayed first.
Argument replies (both in favor and in opposition) are displayed below the original argument.
To follow along, you may find it helpful to show and hide the replies displayed below each argument.
To vote for an argument, use these icons:
You have the power to cast exactly one vote (either up or down) for each argument.
Once you vote, the icon will become grayed out and the argument's score will change.
Yes, you can change your vote.
Debate scores, side scores and tag scores are automatically calculated by an algorithm that primarily takes argument scores into account.
All scores are updated in real-time.
To learn more about the CreateDebate scoring system, check out the FAQ.
When you are ready to voice your opinion, use the Add Argument button to create an argument.
If you would like to address an existing argument, use the Support and Dispute link within that argument to create a new reply.
You are never right Bronto. When your bullshit is exposed you simply swap accounts and provide fake support for yourself. Not only is it childish, but it really illustrates how comprehensively dishonest a person you are.
You have gone into a red herring fallacy
Obviously you do not understand what a red herring fallacy is. If you make a false statement of fact, and I mock you about it, then no, that is not a red herring fallacy. I wish you would stop misapplying these terms (i.e. "red herring", "false equivalence", "demonstrably false" etc...) because it is stupid.
You didn't respond to the topic.
You did not provide a topic (for the third time). You presented a false statement of fact.
If you hate a nation of Jews, you definitionally are an antisemite.
Wrong, you Hasabara toolbag. If you hate a nation of Jews because it is Jewish then you are an anti-Semite. If you hate the nation because it has the worst human rights record in recorded history then you are simply a good person.
You do not get to invent the reason why Israel is hated, so stfu and stop posting Zionist bullshit.
If you hate the nation because it has the worst human rights record in recorded history then you are simply a good person.
In 5,000 years, Israel hasn't killed as many people as the Nazis, Mao, Stalin, or Pol Pot. Hyperbolic crap answers make you look foolish.
You do not get to invent the reason why Israel is hated
If human rights violations was your actual concern, you'd condemn the entire Middle East for its treatment of minorities, women and gays. But you do not do that.
In 5,000 years, Israel hasn't killed as many people as the Nazis, Mao, Stalin, or Pol Pot.
Firstly, Israel was created in 1948 you dumb fuck. Secondly, genocide is not justifiable by referring to other genocides, even if those genocides were worse.
Finally, your statement is a "red herring fallacy" because I made the factually correct assertion that Israel has the worst human rights record in recorded history. Hence, everything you wrote back to me is irrelevant.
You falsely accuse me of "red herring fallacy" in your first post, and then commit a glaring red herring fallacy in your next post. That is literally the level of scumbag you are Bronto.
If human rights violations was your actual concern, you'd condemn the entire Middle East
A glaring tu quoque fallacy. For example, if human rights violations in the Middle East were YOUR actual concern, you would condemn the entire world. Indeed, not only is this a tu quoque fallacy, but it is also a straw man argument. You have never asked me whether I agree with violence in the Middle East. You are simply telling me what my own views are about a topic we have never discussed because you are a dishonest little Zionist fuckbag.
You admit in paragraph one that it's not the worst genocide.
What does that have to do with Israel having the worst human rights record in recorded history you fallacious little scumbag?
You are either lying there or lying here through deductive reasoning
I see. "Deductive reasoning" presumably being your attempt to conflate a single genocide with a total record of abuses stretching over many years.
Bronto, literally everything you say is false, stupid, and dishonest. You are a retarded Zionist troll who couldn't sleep straight in bed on account of being too crooked.
In 70 years, Israel hasn't killed as many as Nazis, Mao, Stalin or Pol Pot.
Which is still a complete deflection of the immorality of genocide. You are attempting to reduce genocide down to a simple numbers game which in and of itself is stupid, but when further added to the fact that you are defending genocide of smaller numbers on the solitary basis that genocides have occurred involving bigger numbers beggars actual belief.
You shrank your own argument. Very dumb.
I don't think I am the one of us who is dumb. I think there might be kind of a double negative effect going on with the way you are presently viewing matters.
You don't condemn the other genocides.
On the contrary, I would be happy to condemn other genocides. But then again, you never start any debates entitled, "If you hate Nazi Germany, you're an anti-Aryan", or "If you hate Mao's China then you are an anti-Asian", do you?
No you don't. You only post this bullshit about Israel because it is absolutely clear who you are brown-nosing, like a dirty little state-sponsored rat.
I don't think I am the one of us who is dumb. I think there might be kind of a double negative effect going on with the way you are presently viewing matters.
The argument was 5,000 years and you shrank it to 70 years thinking you had done something smart. It was bad for your position in the debate to shrink how long they have killed others.
Sure, that’s the small plots of land where all the former Jordanians live in Israel and often stage terrorist attacks from. And the people there, though they are few, ARE STILL COMPLETELY THERE. Probably because, despite their ongoing provocations, NO ONE IS TRYING TO GENOCIDE THEM.
Israel stole the land from Palestine and used force to push them off the land. They killed a shit load of them while stealing their land. They are basically confined to ghettos now and the Israelis are stealing more and more ground. Whether Israel is specifically aiming for genocide or not is irrelevant because that's what they are effectively doing.
Shut the fuck up you disgusting piece of shit. Throwing false accusations of racism at your accuser is not the correct way to defend a genocide charge.
Yes, I'm sure you think it's funny that you get to exterminate the Arabs and then accuse other people of being racist for calling you out on it, but honestly that's just because you are a human toad.
Bombing civilian schools and hospitals is your definition of "not trying"? Gassing civilian compounds with chemical weapons is your definition of "not trying"? That's nice. It must be great to be such a liar. No restrictions when debating.
Israel attacks Palestinian school children with gas and sound bombs
Reporting on Israeli human rights abuses = Anti-Semitism.
Everything which involves criticism of the Israeli apartheid regime is anti-Semitism according to your fascist rhetoric. And then in your next breath you deny being Jewish.
Your lies simply betray you as an untrustworthy, dishonest little shit.
Disowning the entire Middle East, North Africa and Islam isn't anti Arab or anti North African. It's denial of shitty ideologies running around in the desert like a bunch of uncivilized rodents.
I don't know anything about Israel. I see you hating Jews. You are what you hate. You're willing to genocide, be racist, and more as long as it's towards a select group.