CreateDebate


Debate Info

7
5
People NEED water Fuck those people
Debate Score:12
Arguments:7
Total Votes:18
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 People NEED water (4)
 
 Fuck those people (3)

Debate Creator

excon(13064) pic



If you leave drinking water in the desert, are you ENCOURAGING illegal immigration?

Hello:

Or are you saving lives?

excon

People NEED water

Side Score: 7
VS.

Fuck those people

Side Score: 5
1 point

Difficult. Ultimately I support leaving out water, because illegal immigration is hardly a crime worthy of the death penalty. But with that said, the idea of tightening our borders in and of itself is not one without merit. If we simply have open borders, there exists little to no reason for political lines in the first place- without individual countries, all cultures will have rule of law forced upon them by every other culture. Furthermore, such would imply the existence of a centralized government which will simply not be able to have full influence on all corners of the globe, promoting lawless regions where the rule of government is in name only. All of this invites rebellion and secession, which means that the concept of individual countries, even national identity, is as much a part of the human psyche as war.

So we shouldn't simply erase borders, and if we have a border, then in some fashion it must be maintained. Frankly, I'm unconcerned with illegal immigration- there are simply more important things in the world to worry about- but the concept of added security is not without merit. After all, if just anyone can walk in with a dirty bomb in their backpack, that's a pretty major flaw in our national security that needs to be addressed, and not lost in the din of shouting "what about the children" and "build the wall" and "racist".

Side: People NEED water
1 point

You may be both saving lives and encouraging illegal immigration. If someone is considering crossing a desert of death to get into a country illegally, their decision will be swayed by the anticipation of aid, which will reduce the disincentive provided by the desert of death.

Side: People NEED water
1 point

You aren't discourage it per say, but you are saving lives. Which is more important?

Side: People NEED water
2 points

If you leave drinking water in the desert, are you ENCOURAGING illegal immigration?

The STUPID got it going on today !!!!!!!!!!!

So can the STUPID answer how is it your wanted illegal aliens make it without water ?

Side: Fuck those people
0 points

I don't leave law nreakers incentives to break laws. You don't want to die of thirst in the desert? Stay home and go to work to support your family.

Side: Fuck those people
Mingiwuwu(1481) Disputed
0 points

This is probably the dumbest most brutally right-wing nonsense I've read in a while.

Imagine literally being so parched and risking everything legally just to do the very thing you say you're taking away water from them to encourage them to do.

Utter vile shit, you think they run across the border to abuse welfare? THEY ARE RUNNING OUT OF HELL they are grateful so incredibly much to America for letting them in. Stop listen to BULLSHIT from Trump, he's literally mentally deficient, he needs to get put in his fucking place the next election brutally. He bullied his way into the whitehouse, it's about time he got brutally schooled in what real media-manipulating god-tier reputation smearing is. He will get bullied out of the white house 30x harsher than he bullied his way into it and the best part? He may well end up in prison at the end of the entire thing.

Side: People NEED water
Spuds(1077) Disputed
1 point

This is probably the dumbest most brutally right-wing nonsense I've read in a while.

It is? A man has a job and kids and thinks one day, "hmmm. I think I'll say screw my job and drag my family into the desert with no money and hope we don't die." He'd be an idiot.

Side: Fuck those people