Debate Info

Debate Score:2
Total Votes:2
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 If you're raised to kill - are you wrong? (2)

Debate Creator

HannahLlama(83) pic

If you're raised to kill - are you wrong?

Some people have messed up parents that raise them to be cruel and violent. Are the children them criminals if they didn't know better? Why or why not? Should the parents be the one to blame?
Add New Argument

It's a good question. The parents are definitely to blame from a moral perspective, but society still has the problem of the killer they raised. At some point in life we all have to be held responsible for our own actions, even if there is conflict about when that point is or should be. You have given an extreme example of a killer, but your question really applies to indoctrination generally. In fact, there is greater incentive to address your own actions with the given example because killing is ubiquitously agreed to be wrong. But what if your indoctrination was into a religion or political ideology? You might realistically live out your entire life without ever being forced to address it.

1 point

I think there are equal parts blame here. The parents for laying the foundation and the person as they become an adult for continuing to build upon it.