CreateDebate


Debate Info

25
15
Yes No
Debate Score:40
Arguments:32
Total Votes:44
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Yes (17)
 
 No (15)

Debate Creator

Consigliere(183) pic



Is Golf a True Sport?

Based on the dictionary definition of a sport, "an athletic activity requiring skill or physical prowess", give your argument on whether or not Golf should be considered a true sport or merely a game.

Yes

Side Score: 25
VS.

No

Side Score: 15
3 points

If driving around in circles can be a sport, I suppose golf can be too lol.

While golf probably isn't going to keep your heart rate up, or provide any sort of efficient cardie-aerobic workout, it definitely requires a refined physical skill involving hand to eye coordination and superior muscle memory.

Bowling is another example of a sport which relies on physical precision rather than physical exertion. Practicing free-throws or 3-point jump shots in basketball is another. Curling, a rather popular sport in Canada is another example.

Hell, shooting guns is even an Olympic sport.

Side: Yes
Consigliere(183) Disputed
0 points

Golf - Not a sport. No true physical exertion.

Bowling - Not a sport. No true physical exertion.

Nascar - Not a sport. No true physical exertion.

Shooting Guns - Not a sport. No true physical exertion.

Chess - Not a sport. No true physical exertion.

-

Basketball - Is a sport. Considerable physical exertion.

Curling - Is a sport. Considerable physical exertion.

Baseball - Is a sport. Considerable physical exertion.

Hockey - Is a sport. Considerable physical exertion.

Tennis - Is a sport. Considerable physical exertion.

Formula 1 - Is a sport. Considerable physical exertion.

Soccer - Is a sport. Considerable physical exertion.

Football - Is a sport. Considerable physical exertion.

Lacrosse - Is a sport. Considerable physical exertion.

Rugby - Is a sport. Considerable physical exertion.

-

Physical exertion requires physical performance and for one to be in shape.

Physical precision does not require performance nor for one to be in shape.

Physical precision is 95% mental. Chess is also 95% mental. Chess is not a sport.

Side: No
Troy8(2433) Disputed
2 points

Curling - Is a sport. Considerable physical exertion.

Seriously? You're saying golf isn't a sport but curling is? You just lost credibility.

Side: Yes
2 points

So walking 5 miles with a bag of metal on your back isn't physical exertion?

Side: Yes
Consigliere(183) Disputed
1 point

I don't think you read my argument ;)

In the pros, golfers let their caddies carry their bags, and any golfer can use a golf cart to lazily wander the course at their leisure. So no, golf requires no real physical exertion.

Side: No
Troy8(2433) Disputed
1 point

Alright, so walking 5 miles is only "real physical exertion" when you carry a bag? That's far from the truth.

Side: Yes
2 points

The game of golf may not require physical fitness and strength and stamina, but it does require years of practice and an immense amount of skill. I think that is a good enough reason to consider golf a sport.

Side: Yes
2 points

I guess it is, technically speaking. But IMO you have to be a better sport to endure countless hours of wasted life watching it drag on fore ever on tee V. :))

Side: Yes
2 points

it is a sport. its just not as active as other sports like football or basketball.

Side: Yes
Consigliere(183) Disputed
1 point

The definition of a sport, as we established, is something requiring physical exertion, something golf lacks to provide.

Side: No
quickscopz(163) Disputed
1 point

but there is physical exertion. so it qualifies as a sport. are you saying that there is no physical exertion?

Side: Yes
1 point

golf is a sport, why wouldnt it be. you Have to be fairly in shape and have amazing mental awareness

Side: Yes
Consigliere(183) Disputed
1 point

In shape? Are you kidding me? 75% of golfers are elderly mildly obese folks.

Side: No
Consigliere(183) Disputed
-1 points

Why wouldn't it be? I explained in the argument description why it wouldn't be considered one. Try learning to read; it will get you far in life. You do not have to be in shape, most of the golfers I've seen are fairly weighty and quite old. Some of them are demented or suffering Alzheimer's disease, so I wouldn't quite go with the "amazing mental awareness", but rather a good sense of mental skill in judging distance and speed.

Side: No
neverwrong(25) Disputed Banned
1 point

GOLF RULES CONSIGLIERE DROOLS! golf is fun and very athletic, say your golfcart runs out of juice, you may have to walk a lot! and your arms cramp up after a while.

Side: Yes

Of course yes because it is so funny ..... so it a great sport

Side: Yes

Golf brings in the ratings on TV and plenty of people enjoy the Sport.

Side: Yes
1 point

Absolutely, golf is a true sport, blending precision and strategy. Now, speaking of the excitement beyond the fairways, online sport betting adds another layer of thrill to the sports enthusiast's experience. It's not just about chance; it's about calculated risks and informed choices. For those intrigued by the adrenaline of betting, https://1xbet.com.gh/ emerges as a platform offering enticing odds and a plethora of modern sport betting options. Elevate your sports engagement by exploring the dynamic world of online betting – where strategy meets chance, and every play is a new opportunity.

Side: Yes

I think golf is a game, not a sport. The dictionary defines it as an activity requiring physical exertion or prowess, neither of which golf requires. 70% of people who play golf are elderly and overweight, and they play very well. You don't even have to walk, let alone run, in golf thanks to golf carts. And don't give me that "In the pro tournaments you can't use a cart" crap; your caddie carries the heavy stuff for you, plus there was a handicapped participant who used to play in the tournaments and the supreme court deemed it okay to let him use a golf cart to get around the hole. That could never happen in any real sport.

Side: No
Intangible(4934) Disputed
2 points

. 70% of people who play golf are elderly and overweight, and they play very well

That means nothing, a lot of elderly people play tennis and so do overweight people, but tennis is a sport.

plus there was a handicapped participant who used to play in the tournaments

Just because someone handicap plays doesn't mean it isn't a sport.

Ever heard of wheelchair basketball?

Side: Yes
Consigliere(183) Disputed
1 point

That means nothing, a lot of elderly people play tennis and so do overweight people, but tennis is a sport.

Tennis is a sport, and to be a pro you have to be lean and in prime condition. When retired old people play tennis they do little to no moving, simply stand there and lightly tap the ball over the net. You obviously haven't watched any professional tennis.

Just because someone handicap plays doesn't mean it isn't a sport. Ever heard of wheelchair basketball?

That isn't what I said. Handicapped people can't play regular sports; that's why other activities such as wheelchair basketball are created. And I do in fact consider wheelchair basketball specifically a sport, because it takes a lot of physical exertion, probably even more exertion than regular basketball, to roll a wheelchair around. You need a lot of upper body strength to roll not only yourself but the weight of the wheelchair around.

Side: No
1 point

golf is not a sport you just have to keep walking and hitting the ball .... one does get tired after a game but you don't even get sweaty

Side: No
1 point

how can it be a sport when all you do is hit the ball with a stick and add commentators that make it sound as if you are lebron james winning the game with a buzzer beater?

baseball has faster action then golf, bowling too.

compare the speeds of athletes in soccer to the leisurely walking in golf. if golf is a sport then it is one for people with too much time on their hands.

Side: No