Debate Stats:

Debate Score:17
Arguments:8
Total Votes:22
Ends:Never
Graph Updates Live
install flash for graphs
Religion of Violence Religion of Peace

Sort By Tags:

All Tags
Peaceful (1)

Debate Creator:

vast2zero(14) pic

Are you trying to figure out how this debate works? Show Quick Tips

Is Islam a religion of violence or a religion of peace?
Muslims all over the world insist that Islam is a religion that espouses peace and understanding. Yet everyday we read or watch news of violence made by their fanatics. What's your say on this?

Religion of Violence
Side Score:
7
VS.
Religion of Peace
Side Score:
10
Add New Argument
Add New Argument
– MyPic shunted(113) Vote Up Vote Down
2
points 

According to the Koran a Muslim who renounces Islam should be put to death. Once you are in you can't get out. I don't know exactly what the questioner means by 'religion of violence' but I think a religion that kills adherents for wanting to get out ought to be considered violent.

Posted 124 days ago
– MyPic kuyakano(2) Vote Up Vote Down
2
points 

Terrorists or freedom fighters. Depends on your point of view. From my point of view a lot of muslims are violent in the name of islam. The so called moderate ones remain quiet. The sharia law can be quite unforgiving. In the past laws in christian countries were not much different, but christians have grown beyond that and appear more humane now.

Since the beginning of islam, it has been opposing other religions agressively and it does not seem this will end anytime soon.

Muslims want one world-wide base religion only; Islam. Non muslims are lesser beings in their view, fit to do away with, at best tolerated if useful.

To islam, not believing is unthinkable. Eradication of undesirables, reason and inconvenient science justifiable. Their message of peace includes putting nay sayers to the sword.

You could say that the other mainstream religion has not been that much different in the past, and you would be right. But dealing with the here and now, islam is violent.

Posted 113 days ago
– MyPic smilnjan(107) Opposed Vote Up Vote Down
1
point  

So saying, you can definitely use this argument for any organized religion. How many wars were fought in the name of Christianity? I believe religion is being used as a springboard for certain people to force their views on others or to get power or stay in power. If one feels that others that do not believe in what they believe is a 'lesser being' and chooses to go to war or be active in terrorism, that isn't necessarily the religion itself, but the persons interpreting said religion. Many people believe that those active in the Church of Satan are violent people, but the ones I've met, and I've met a few, are very peaceful people.

Posted 113 days ago
Supporting Evidence: Official Church of Satan website (www.churchofsatan.com)
– MyPic borme(502) Vote Up Vote Down
2
points 

I think that at it's root, Islam is a religion of peace. However, extremists who have an agenda to push brainwash millions of young Muslims in to thinking that their purpose on this Earth is to kill anyone who's not a Muslim. This is not the teachings of the Koran, yet these people make others believe that it is.

Posted 125 days ago
– MyPic smilnjan(107) Vote Up Vote Down
2
points 

I suppose it is much like the Mormons, it depends on the sect. not all Mormons are polygamists, but they all call themselves Mormon. So, for the most part, I believe that the "main stream" religion is peaceful, but it is the 'stray' sects that we most remember as violent.

Posted 123 days ago
– MyPic Klepto(4) Vote Up Vote Down
1
point  

Welcome to the third world, where tribal ties are still in play and violence is considered an acceptable means of societal control. The acts of Muslims extremists are pretty much the same as rebels in Africa, Islam just gives an effective point of focus, regardless of its doctrines - this is the same for any other religion. I seriously doubt that if Islam and Christianity's positions were switched - if Islam were popular in the West and Christianity were popular in the Middle East - we'd see an appreciable difference in how the world is today.

Posted 119 days ago
– MyPic Bluefish7(43) Vote Up Vote Down
1
point  

extremists are not part of islam, those who commit violence are seperate.

Posted 113 days ago
– MyPic Lucasban(101) Vote Up Vote Down
1
point  

Most muslims are peaceful, then they get some crazies wrecking everything.

Posted 46 days ago | Tagged As: Peaceful


About CreateDebate
The CreateDebate Blog
Newsletter Archive
Take a Tour
Help/FAQ
Sharing Tools
Send Beta Invites
Bookmarklets
Partner Buttons
RSS & XML Feeds
Reach Out
Advertise
Contact Us
Report Abuse
Twitter
Legal Stuff
User Agreement
Privacy Policy
Creative Commons

©2008 CreateDebate, LLC All Rights Reserved. User content, unless source quoted, licensed under a Creative Commons License.