CreateDebate


Debate Info

21
5
Yes, it is effective No, it is a waste of time
Debate Score:26
Arguments:17
Total Votes:28
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Yes, it is effective (13)
 
 No, it is a waste of time (4)

Debate Creator

addltd(5144) pic



Is blackmail and effective tool to get what you want?

I am interested in the opinion of all the users on this site as to whether blackmail is an effective means to get what you want from someone.

I have my own opinion which I will share below.

Yes, it is effective

Side Score: 21
VS.

No, it is a waste of time

Side Score: 5
2 points

Yo dat depends da type o' blackmail you use, soft or hard.. , wOrd!

Side: Yes, it is effective

As a black male, do you find yourself to be effective at helping others get what they want? ;)

Side: Yes, it is effective
2 points

...... Yes, I'm evil........hehehe..............................

Side: Yes, it is effective
2 points

It's not necessarily a moral way of handling things, but it can be effective when dealing with terrorists and criminals. When placed in a situation where innocent lives are at stake, I can imagine black mail being a smart alternative when dealing with people. I personally would consider it in this scenario.

Then there is the really dirty blackmail that we hear about coming from politics, businesses, law firms, etc,. The kind used to shut somebody up. However, I'm sure it is effective in many cases.

Side: Yes, it is effective
2 points

well, blackmail is based on manipulation, it is not a good thing, but it seems to be highly effective. the person you are blackmailing will eventually break down and give in..so you will get what you want. It depends on how serious you are...

Side: Yes, it is effective
1 point

Not a nice way to get what you want, but yes I say it is effective.

Side: Yes, it is effective
1 point

It could be a way of getting what you want but it could be mean and abusive since you are controlling the person to get what you want and sometimes people threaten you like for instance you do something for them or else they get shot.

Side: Yes, it is effective
1 point

I see people saying "no, blackmail is bad" e.t.c. This isn't about whether it's good or not, the point is blackmail is exceedingly effective! How do you think Al Capone managed. How do you think politicians manage, all the other crooks and gangsters! Yes blackmail is very effective.

Side: Yes, it is effective

It depends on whom you are blackmailing.

Humans vary in degrees on value upon things around them and upon themselves.

What you may assume to be important to someone may be completely insignificant to them.

If we are to assume that you are intelligent and have picked up all the loose ends of your blackmail attempt... then yes, it's very effective.

It can able be morally justifiable, but this debate doesn't seem to be about morals, and moreover, the effectiveness of blackmail (even though I could argue that immoral things are ineffective, I won't derail the topic that is supposed to be debated).

Side: Yes, it is effective
1 point

Blackmail is effective because it works, just like manipulation. However they are both wrong forms of getting what you want, because it's dishonest and wicked to do. Why not get what you want by working hard, and if you can't obtain it then it's not for you to have. If you have to blackmail somebody for something, then you don't deserve what you want.

Side: Yes, it is effective
1 point

..............................................................................................

Side: Yes, it is effective

The person doing it knows he can get what he wants. It is a dirty scheme.

Side: Yes, it is effective
1 point

Not really because if they threaten you with something and you refuse to do there demands then they take action on the threat they lose their bargining chip

Side: No, it is a waste of time
1 point

But there is always the possibility it isn't they only bargaining chip. They can have more on you, or someone else who saw what happened to you. By showing that they are serious about their threat, they become more immtemidating. Sure you can always say no to them, but the result boosts the the credibilty of their threats for their future endevior, so it is a win win for them.

Side: Yes, it is effective

No, blackmail is harmless. It is merely the threat for an exchange without the use if coercion.

Side: No, it is a waste of time
1 point

Blackmail? No. Try whitemailing people... I don't know what it is 'cause I just made it up, but shit... how it works.

Side: No, it is a waste of time
1 point

No, it just makes people angry- it'd be a good distraction though.

Side: No, it is a waste of time