CreateDebate


Debate Info

5
2
EFFORT TALENT!
Debate Score:7
Arguments:4
Total Votes:7
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 EFFORT (3)
 
 TALENT! (1)

Debate Creator

Terry Here!(60) pic



Is effort more important or talent more important to WIN?

EFFORT

Side Score: 5
VS.

TALENT!

Side Score: 2
2 points

For my answer I will assume that "WIN" means "live a good life."

In order to win, you do not need to be exceptionally talented in the same way that others are. Effort is of paramount importance because it takes effort to recognize the most important talents.

One of the comforting things about talent is that no one is talented in every way. If you exert enough effort getting to know yourself, you will find that there are things you excel at that others struggle with. I do think discovering what your natural talents are to be very important.

You need to study and learn to be sure, but what are you most curious about? Try absorbing and mentally retaining information from a book (or class) that you aren't the slightest bit curious about and it will be aggravating to say the least. It will seem like a waste of time.

To win you should be doing things you are passionate about. This sort of effort may be very strenuous but you won't mind because it WON'T be boring.

I am going to stop rambling here.

Side: EFFORT
1 point

Talent is important. But, even if you coat talent with out effort it is gonna be useless. Besides, with effort, you always learn.

Side: EFFORT
2 points

But althogh you make a big effort, if you dont have any talent in you, then isnt the effort nothing if you dont really have any talent compared to the one who have a greater talent then you and putting in the same effort as you? so i think talent is more important then the effort you put in. if you dont have any talent in this particular thing, no matter how you put in effort, there will not be the same result as the one who have a greater talent than yours and he also puts in some effort.

if you wanna do good in one particular thing, you have to have some talent in you so as to do better after you had put in the great effort.

Side: TALENT!
Peekaboo(704) Disputed
2 points

Some people seem to do badly at school no matter how hard they try, so they tell themselves that they just don't have the talent. But in many cases that's not true.

I've been tutoring classmates for years, and I've come to think that the real reason they do badly is that they're not working the right way. It's not that they don't have talent, or they're not studying hard enough... they're just not studying effectively.

I had a friend in law school who spent 2 hours every evening reading her textbook, but she kept failing the tests. She told me she had no talent for law and might as well quit. But when I looked at her test the real reason was obvious. The test was conducted in essay format, and she didn't know how to write essays. Most of the time she wrote irrelevant answers, and even when she was writing the right thing, her answer was completely unorganised. She should have been practising analysing test questions and writing essays, not memorising textbooks.

I had another friend, this time from philosophy class. He could write well, but he was barely passing. I looked at his assignments, and again found that it wasn't about talent. The problem was that there was, well, no philosophy in his assignments. He wasn't arguing for a position; he was just writing long introductions to the topics. I suggested that he read articles from academic journals, figure out how they argued, and copy them. He got A- at the end of the semester, a big jump up from C.

That's just 2 examples; I could list more. (I'm an example as well: I used to think I was hopeless at physical education, but eventually realised the reason I kept losing was simply that I didn't practise enough, even though I thought I did.) My point is, a lot of people think that they have no talent at something when in fact they just haven't been doing it the right way. "Talented" people are just people who work hard and work right.

Side: EFFORT