CreateDebate


Debate Info

5
10
Fair Unfair
Debate Score:15
Arguments:13
Total Votes:15
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Fair (4)
 
 Unfair (9)

Debate Creator

rlinehan(38) pic



Is giving 3-4 hours oh homework a night for sixth graders fair

Fair

Side Score: 5
VS.

Unfair

Side Score: 10

Well, it depends if you want to be smart or a idiot.-------------

Side: fair

Would you rather they got less and failed? Or that they got more homework and never had a minute to themselves?

Side: fair
rlinehan(38) Disputed
1 point

so what r u saying...it is fair or not?????????????????? cause im confused

Side: Unfair
TERMINATOR(6781) Disputed
1 point

I was asking you what you thought. I think it fair.

Side: fair

It is fair, if everyone in the class has the same requirements. But, it's really not a matter of fair or unfair. It's more a matter of the benefit it achieves. Anything that keeps children from sitting in front of a TV for 3 to 4 hours a day is a good thing.

Side: fair
2 points

Well, the creator didn't mention the circumstance.

is it per day? or 1 day?

One day I have no problem with, but if I remember correctly, it's still pretty important that sixth graders get a chance to play, and be creative, so everyday is too much I think.

That said though, at some point you'll have to get used to 12 hrs plus of study a day if you want to be a professional level anything...

still, sixth grade's a bit early for all that.

Side: Unfair
1 point

yes...100% definitly what about a free life of a kid? hmm what teacher thought of that

Side: Unfair
1 point

Totally unfair! When I was in 6th grade I was top of the class in everything. I did practically no homework. As a result, I played outside more and was much healthier than those sitting at computers doing 3-4 hours of homework.

Side: Unfair
1 point

I am in Twelfth Grade and I only do that amount now... I'm Dux of the school... Ducky930 might be Dux next year, eh?

Side: Unfair

People forget that students are not paid to do their homework. Even paid professionals do not bring 3-4 hours of work back to their homes. Ask an employee to do that and he would probably go to a union.

Side: Unfair
1 point

NOt fair, we have lives to live, we don't like being stuck inside with homework!

Side: Unfair
1 point

It is TOTALLY unfair!!!! You basically are doing school work ALL DAY!!!!!!! which I do NOT approve.

Side: Unfair

That's way too much homework for someone in the 6th Grade.

Side: Unfair