CreateDebate


Debate Info

4
4
HumanLivesInGeneral JustAbortion
Debate Score:8
Arguments:14
Total Votes:8
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 HumanLivesInGeneral (4)
 
 JustAbortion (4)

Debate Creator

KJVPrewrath(967) pic



This is a private debate. See the FAQ for more info.

Challenge Debate: Is prolife just about abortion, or do human lives in general matter?

KJVPrewrath(967)

HumanLivesInGeneral

Side Score: 4
VS.
themadgadfly(889)

JustAbortion

Side Score: 4

I am prolife across the board. Free healthcare, birth control which prevents abortion, adoption reform, abolish torture and execution, limit war to Constitutional congressional approval for just reasons only, and if the is not prolife, I am not prolife. Prolife is supposed to say all lives matter, but alleged prolifers pursue the very things I want to avoid. Bwrnie Sanders does have more respect for born people than Trump.

Side: HumanLivesInGeneral
themadgadfly(889) Disputed Banned
1 point

You can't really be pro-life across the board because there isn't a board. There's being against abortion. That's it. Everything else you've talked about is not part of the pro-life movement. There's a free healthcare movement, as well as an adoption reform movement, but you can't group it all into one thing just because of the wording. Pro-life = anti-abortion.

Side: JustAbortion

What my opponant fails to reaslize is that from womb to tomb, people have rights. Why be prolife if you engafe in things that cause death like Trump making cuts to Medicaid causing people to die without healthcare?

Side: HumanLivesInGeneral
themadgadfly(889) Disputed Banned
1 point

What my opponent fails to realize is for one, how to spell, and two, that people do have rights but those who decide to murder others do not have the right to live. Why be your version of pro-life (which is false) if you can't punish the man/woman who murdered or raped the victim?

Where are the statistics to prove that making cuts to Medicaid directly lead to deaths? I haven't seen any, most likely because tax cuts don't kill people. If an organization can't financially support itself, so be it. It's not the government's responsibility to throw money at an institution that's on the edge of its lifespan.

Side: JustAbortion
KJVPrewrath(967) Clarified
1 point

You are not God, that you have the right to tske a human life when life in prison will do. This is suddenly a prolife is bullshit debate, because prolife conservatives are full of shit. I consider the fetus to be a person, but so is my rapist. Do not pretend to care about me, if you wont listen to what I am saying. When the Pharisees wanted to stone thgat woman, He said let He who is without sin cast the first stone. When God speaketh.

Side: HumanLivesInGeneral

I can't be prolife for all humans? Fine. I am not prolife, I am porojustice, because you are a raging conservative hypocrite.

Side: HumanLivesInGeneral
themadgadfly(889) Clarified Banned
1 point

I can't be prolife for all humans?

No, you can't because not all humans can be aborted, as that is the basis of pro-life. Pro-life = anti-abortion.

I am not prolife, I am porojustice

Porojustice?

Pro-justice isn't a thing, KJV. If you'd like to start it, fine, but don't be surprised when almost zero people take your ridiculous views as their own.

you are a raging conservative hypocrite

How have I been a hypocrite? Because I want murderers to die because they've proven their worth or lack-thereof? And because I don't want unborn babies to die for no good reason?

Side: HumanLivesInGeneral
KJVPrewrath(967) Clarified
1 point

I am Projustice, meaning I value all humans. You love the fetus and hate the born person, and that is not okay.

Side: HumanLivesInGeneral
1 point

When you go onto the Merriam-Webster Dictionary, the definition of pro-life is literally "opposed to abortion".

Supporting Evidence: Pro-life as defined by the Merriam-Webster Dictionary (www.merriam-webster.com)
Side: JustAbortion
KJVPrewrath(967) Disputed
1 point

Prolife is to value human life in general. That is the spirit of the prolife movement.

Side: HumanLivesInGeneral
themadgadfly(889) Clarified Banned
1 point

No, actually, the spirit of the pro-life movement is to make abortion illegal. Pick up a dictionary.

Side: HumanLivesInGeneral