CreateDebate


Debate Info

8
6
Yes, it's important. No, it's not important.
Debate Score:14
Arguments:12
Total Votes:14
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Yes, it's important. (7)
 
 No, it's not important. (5)

Debate Creator

Yakeyglee(45) pic



Is reading fiction books/stories important?

Is reading fiction books and/or stories as important as it's hyped up to be?  Are nonfiction books an acceptable substitute?  Is there something of great importance that one gains from reading fiction that's not gained from reading nonfiction?  I'm not asking if people should or should not read fiction.  I'm simply asking if it's important for people to do so.

Yes, it's important.

Side Score: 8
VS.

No, it's not important.

Side Score: 6
1 point

I would say that it is. The two genre's address a myriad of the same questions but in different ways, something important for a balanced understanding. I also think that with fiction we have a way to explore our hopes dreams and imagination. Just as nonfiction allows us to satiate our intellectual curiosities in the realms of reality.

Side: Yes, it's important.

I've just read a fantastic essay by Paul Auster for my English class about how human beings crave and need stories. I absolutely agree with him. We all love stories, and we all need stories, which can come in any format including books, television, movies, and even art or music.

Side: Yes, it's important.
Yakeyglee(45) Disputed
1 point

I would agree with that too, but just because something's a story doesn't mean that it's fiction. One could crave a real story about someone's childhood just as they could crave a story about a fictional characters' childhood.

Side: No, it's not important.

Yes, that's true, but I don't think a person would crave solely real stories and disregard fiction.

Side: Yes, it's important.
1 point

Some fiction books make you think "what if", and I think that's important to expand our minds. For example, books that talk about the future, a personal favorite of mine, can make someone think about what to prepare for, or can make them just think of the possibilities. Expanding your mind is important, and fiction books can do that for you.

Side: Yes, it's important.
1 point

I would say it reallly isn't important because I don't read that many fiction books. Sometimes I do read fiction books but only if its really good!

Side: No, it's not important.
2 points

Ya, like the bible;-) Sorry, I just couldn't resist.

Side: No, it's not important.
Srom(12206) Disputed
2 points

To me the Bible isn't fiction. To me it is evidence that Jesus was alive and that people saw Him. Also it tells about the history of Israel and prophets and it also tells prophesy that has been fulfilled

Side: Yes, it's important.
1 point

Lol, I was so thinking that when I read his. But you beat me to the punch :)

Side: No, it's not important.
1 point

Well, no wonder your linguistic abilities stop where the Bible ends. And this is an honest question, but what type of books would you consider "good"?

Side: Yes, it's important.
Srom(12206) Disputed
1 point

I would say that the type of books I think is good is nonfiction because its true and it was documented like the Bible is nonfiction. I once in awhile read fiction story books but not a lot. I mostly read the Bible because its nonfiction

Side: No, it's not important.