Debate Info

15
13
true false
Debate Score:28
Arguments:19
Total Votes:29
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 true (10)
 
 false (9)

Debate Creator

atypican(1874) pic



It's unfair for gays to be sent to prison

true

Side Score: 15
VS.

false

Side Score: 13
3 points

It is unfair for anybody to be sent to prison. Prison is a barbaric form of revenge for past crimes, not a center for rehabilitation. Many prisoners suffer severe abuse, sexual and physical, not to mention the emotional toll encountered when one is locked away for many years. Nope, nobody ought to be sent to prison.

361 days ago | Side: true
2 points

If you are not simply in favor of prison reform (so they become centers of rehabilitation) what do you suggest ought to be done with people who fail to abide by community standards?

361 days ago | Side: true
1 point

you can always flee to Sweeden; their facilities are really nice there, its the kind of thing that not even a man who worked his entire life would ever dream about. And the best part is, the Sweedish government won't ever give any one of its prisoners to the US or anyone, which means you can be safe and secure, and think about what you did to those poor children over coffee, watching your flat-screen in your single. And in case the cafeteria food isn't good enough, there's always the option of cooking it yourself with your private kitchen with bar-less windows (as if bars would be needed there)

361 days ago | Side: true
1 point

Well, I'm not really sure what you mean. Do you mean for gays to be sent to prison just because they're gay or for any gays to be sent to prison for any reason?

The former... true. The latter, not true. The main terrible thing about prison is incarceration, not rape. Sure, it's advantageous to enjoy sex with someone of the same gender if you're in prison, but that doesn't make prison much better.

Prison is a terrible place. I sort of agree with Liber that in most cases, imprisonment is barbaric.

361 days ago | Side: true
1 point

The debate is kind of a joke. Seriously though for low income folks, cities are rather like prisons (rife with all the negatives you and Liber mentioned) and if I wasn't a parent, and committing a crime meant that I'd be locked up in a facility with sex starved females, it wouldn't seem to me to be much worse than "freedom" at all. And why should gays get to be locked up with the gender they prefer to have sexual relations with, while heterosexuals are denied that privilege. Its not fair. Come on..... how can you say that being locked up surrounded by sex starved people of your preferred gender wouldn't make prison much better?

361 days ago | Side: true
1 point

If you where gay, would you like to be sent to prison?

Gays are still people even if you think that they are really weird.

If god wants them to be gay then that is what they should be.

358 days ago | Side: true
3 points

? if they commit a crime that deserves prison, they should be sent to prison just like anyone else. They arent exluded from being sent to prison simply because of their sexual preference.

361 days ago | Side: false
atypican(1874) Disputed
0 points

Opportunity to have heterosexual sex is effectively denied to prisoners by segregating the prison system by sex. Homosexuals on the other hand are sent to a sexual playground. It's unfair.

361 days ago | Side: true
2 points

That's.. awful of you. And ignorant. I hope you're trolling. Just because I'm straight doesn't mean I want to be raped by a prison full of men. Gay people have feelings too, and are capable of being traumatized by a man.

247 days ago | Side: false
markml0528(1228) Disputed
1 point

I do not believe this is why prisoners are separated by gender, although I'm certain it is a factor of course.

Aren't prisoners separated by gender because men are stronger than women, in most cases? It would undoubtedly lead to a massive spike in prison rape as well. It also opens up the possibility of the female prisoner getting pregnant, which would further complicate the prison system.

247 days ago | Side: false

As long as it gets people off rush hour traffic, I'm all for it ;)

361 days ago | Side: false

No more than it is unfair for anyone else to be sent to prison. Someone being gay does not make them any different to anyone else (except for being gay), so they should be treated in exactly the same way as anyone else.

361 days ago | Side: false
atypican(1874) Disputed
1 point

I meant considering that only gays get to be locked up with the gender they prefer to have as sexual partners.

361 days ago | Side: true

why the fuck are you arguing this. its a really stupid question

361 days ago | Side: false
atypican(1874) Disputed
3 points

I'll just consider you wrong unless you make a convincing argument. Calling it stupid is a far cry from explaining why. And BTW you are of course welcome to create a debate based on a smart question if you are capable. I suppose I should regard your last debate topic as brilliant, thought provoking and original?

361 days ago | Side: true

You need a better description. But if a Gay commits murder, they shouldn't be let off the hook simply because he or she has a different sexual preference but if the Gay is sent to prison for the fact of being gay, then that's not right.

361 days ago | Side: false
1 point

that is an amazing point. you are completely right!!!!!!!!!!!!!

361 days ago | Side: false
1 point

NO if you did something wrong then you did something wrong & you deserve 2 go 2 prison it doesnt matter if youre straight, gay, black or white!!!!! If you dd sometrhing wrong then it doesnt matter who you are or what you believe in.

361 days ago | Side: false
Popular Debates: If we ever found out the location of aliens should we attempt to communicate with them? If we ever found out the location of joecavalry should we attempt to communicate "Should Same Sex Family Members be Allowed to Marry?"



About CreateDebate
The CreateDebate Blog
Take a Tour
Help/FAQ
Newsletter Archive
Sharing Tools
Invite Your Friends
Bookmarklets
Partner Buttons
RSS & XML Feeds
Reach Out
Advertise
Contact Us
Report Abuse
Twitter
Basic Stuff
User Agreement
Privacy Policy
Sitemap
Creative Commons



©2013 TidyLife, Inc. All Rights Reserved. User content, unless source quoted, licensed under a Creative Commons License.
Debate Forum | Big shout-outs to The Bloggess and Andy Cohen.