CreateDebate


Debate Info

15
17
Agree noggerstein shmetzerfield
Debate Score:32
Arguments:10
Total Votes:45
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Agree (4)
 
 noggerstein shmetzerfield (6)

Debate Creator

DarkElfMage(61) pic



Jews created capitalism

Agree

Side Score: 15
VS.

noggerstein shmetzerfield

Side Score: 17
5 points

You said Moses & the Exodus didn't exist, so nonexisting races couldn't have created Capitalism.

Side: Agree
carterusmbot(6) Disputed
2 points

You said Moses & the Exodus didn't exist

No he didn't. I said that. And I stand by it.

so nonexisting races couldn't have created Capitalism.

He didn't ask if Jews were a race. He asked if they created capitalism. Do you even speak English you dumb Nazi fuck?

Side: noggerstein shmetzerfield
CuteSarah(14) Disputed
1 point

How can a race that doesn't exist create anything?

Side: Agree
-3 points
Spuds(1074) Disputed
5 points

There are just some things we do automatically without thought or planning

Yet liberalism tries to brainwash what we naturally do and think out of us.

Side: noggerstein shmetzerfield
carterusmbot(6) Disputed
2 points

There are just some things we do automatically without thought or planning.

You mean like lying?

Ex Con Isn't Even Jewish
Side: noggerstein shmetzerfield
CuteSarah(14) Disputed
1 point

Nobody ever watches your videos. Thought I'd let you know.

Side: Agree
2 points

The truth is I don't know if they did or they didn't. They certainly know how to exploit capitalism for their own gain though, given that 40 percent of US billionaires are Jewish.

One thing they definitely did create is Christianity, so one could argue they are ultimately responsible for millions of deaths. That said, they would be equally responsible for Christian charity.

Judaism is the most dangerous of all the religions. That's what I believe. Fundamentalists are fundamentalists, but the Jewish ones have nuclear weapons and considerable power -- both political and economic.

Side: noggerstein shmetzerfield
2 points

Hitler certainly thought so. His anti Semitic rhetoric often went hand in hand with his anti capitalist rhetoric.

In truth, they made contributions, but can hardly be said to have created it. The origins of capitalism rest more heavily on the situation in England which lead to the Magna Carta. Basically, the various Lords were able to accrue enough military might to make demands of the King, such as property rights.

Capitalism wasn’t created in a single place and time, it developed over time, was articulated by Adam Smith, and named in the mid 1800’s. The word was used as a pejorative by Marx in Das Kapital.

Side: noggerstein shmetzerfield
2 points

Nonsense . Since evidence for trade is found even in palaeolithic culture, it can be seen as natural to human societies.capitalism emerged from earlier trade once merchants had acquired sufficient wealth (referred to as 'primitive capital') to begin investing in increasingly productive technologies

.

As usual you’re wrong yet again

Amarel is correct when he states Marx used the term as a perjorative , this is typical of the hypocrisy of Marx and Engels who were Capitalists through and through , incidentally they were also both rapists , raging alcoholics and investors in the stock market 😳😳😳

From an excellent piece in the Spectator regarding the rapist and hypocrite Marx

Marx was a liar, adulterer, snob, sponger, boor, hypocrite and domestic tyrant. He destroyed everything he touched, from newspapers and clubs to the First International. He ran through several substantial legacies and played the stock exchange, while preaching that inheritance and private property should be abolished.

As a young man, he had married Jenny von Westphalen against the wishes of her family. As a father, he forbade his favourite daughter, Eleanor, from marrying the Frenchman she loved, preferring one of his disciples, Edward B. Aveling, who made her his mistress. (Aveling secretly married an actress, and persuaded Eleanor to enter a suicide pact. She drank the poison; he did not.) Marx never acknowledged his illegitimate child by his maid, and insisted that the boy be fostered to prevent scandal.

Wheen finds it hard to admit that Marx was a man of violent and paranoid racial prejudices, with a severe case of Jewish self-hatred.

The notorious essay "On the Jewish Question" is excused on the grounds that its author was defending the Jews; yet his works and correspondence are peppered with anti-Semitic epithets, usually combined with scatological insults.

Here is a piece from the Telegraph regarding the rapist and champagne socialist Engels

Engels was a champagne socialist. He thought it was ‘beastly’ being a bourgeois and a manufacturer, but he was quite good at it. He justified his factory job by saying that he was using the money he made from exploiting the mill workers to liberate the proletariat by funding Marx’s great book. As a socialist he didn’t always practise what he preached. He hunted regularly with the Cheshire Hunt, jumping fences with the local squires. He lived with an illiterate Irish factory girl, Mary Burns. This made him guilty of the sin that he accused the factory owners of committing, taking advantage of the power relationship for sexual purposes.

After the publication of Das Kapital, Engels moved to London and lived in a house in Primrose Hill. His income came from investing in stocks and shares, but he claimed that this was ideologically sound because the stock exchange merely adjusted the surplus value stolen from the workers. Marx’s family — his daughters and blood-sucking sons-in-law — sponged off Engels shamelessly. To his credit, the generous Engels never resented this. After Mary Burns died, he lived in a Bohemian ménage with her sister Lizzie, kept open house and downed vast quantities of claret and German beer. It all sounds rather jolly. Tristram Hunt argues that Engels didn’t marry Lizzie until she was on her deathbed because he was convinced of the hypocrisy of bourgeois marriage, but Engels was also a womaniser who was once accused of rape.

Side: noggerstein shmetzerfield