CreateDebate


Debate Info

16
8
Mike Tyson Shaquille O'neal
Debate Score:24
Arguments:12
Total Votes:28
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Mike Tyson (7)
 
 Shaquille O'neal (5)

Debate Creator

nip66(14) pic



Mike Tyson V. Shaquille O'neal (cage match)

round one: Fight!
hide video
the winner is the real american

Mike Tyson

Side Score: 16
VS.

Shaquille O'neal

Side Score: 8
4 points
Never underestimate the capability of a clearly insane person. Shaq is so big and slow that Tyson would be able to land a combo (and bite his ear off) before Shaq even knew what hit him.
Side: Mike Tyson
3 points
First of all, I would like to thank nip66 for proposing one of the best debates on this website to date. Secondly, I would like to back tyson in this one. Basketball is not football and even though most fights are bracketed by weight class, which would give shaq the obvious favor in this match, I am a firm believer in biblical stories including the famous David vs. Goliath parable. It is just a matter of being taught what to do in a certain situation. Tyson knows how to scrap and shaq does not. It's as simple as that.
Side: Mike Tyson
2 points

Mike Tyson is a boxer. He knows fighting.

Side: Mike
2 points

Mike Tyson was a professionally trained fighter. Shaq shoots a basketball. Really who put stuff up for Shaq? Mike Tyson has fists that move faster than you can follow with your eyes with enough power to knock you out with a playful jab. Shaq would stand there getting his face bashed in with his arms flailing

Side: Mike Tyson
2 points

dude size does not matter that much shaq may be big but big and dumb couldn't win against the real man of steel.

Side: Mike Tyson
1 point
I agree, insanity wins over size any day, just watch the video below. Also, never mess with a guy that tattoos his face.
Just remember, Shaq didn't really know kung fu, that was just his terrible video game (shaqfu.com)
mmm ears.
Side: Mike Tyson

I think Mike Tyson would win because he has the stamina and the strength.

Side: Mike Tyson
2 points
It is an argument I have participated in since about 8th grade with various friends. Back then, I insisted tyson would come out victorious by virtue of him being insane. But I have changed my opinion. To me, Shaq's size makes any attempt by Tyson to get a punch in worthless. Lets try and think about each man as "in his prime."
Side: Shaquille O'neal
2 points
Shaq would Kazaam Tyson in a cage match, especially if it involved a basketball or a magic lamp.
Side: Shaquille O'neal
1 point

Shaq's reach is much more than tyson and his hands are 12 inches from palm to middle finger given him more power

Side: Shaquille O'neal
1 point

It may seem to you that my opinion is subjective. Well.. most likely it is. In general, I think that comparing two different sports is wrong. But if you look from a humanistic point of view, I like Shakil because of his attentiveness to his fans. I usually use the local sports site but even there there is a separate page for it) - https://in.1xbet.com/ Mike has also achieved a lot, but he is more of a celebrity than an athlete now.

Side: Shaquille O'neal
-1 points

shaq would definitely win. he is black, huge, and over 7 feet tall. he would pick tyson up by his head and give him an ass whoopin'.

Side: Shaquille O'neal