CreateDebate


Debate Info

24
18
Rebel Valor!! More Unneeded Killing...
Debate Score:42
Arguments:30
Total Votes:42
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Rebel Valor!! (15)
 
 More Unneeded Killing... (15)

Debate Creator

chatturgha(1631) pic



Moammar Gadhafi's Death?

This is a relatively young topic, so I'd like to get your opinions while they're young.

Rebel Valor!!

Side Score: 24
VS.

More Unneeded Killing...

Side Score: 18
3 points

Justice for the victims of Pan Am 103. As for the future of Lybia, only time will tell... they could end up with something even worse.

Side: Rebel Valor!!
2 points

They deserved to take justice in their own hands. It was their own issue, and they solved it their own way. We were right to not stick our noses in their business and put that dictator through an international trial.

Side: Rebel Valor!!
2 points

I agree, although we did stick our noses in it some with the air support and the rebels should repay us for the cost as they have said that they will.

Side: Rebel Valor!!
garry77777(1796) Disputed
1 point

The real events of Pan Am 103 have never fully been disclosed, the man Al Ma Grahi always protested his innocence, i don't know at lot about it myself, there was definitely Libyan involvement but i don't think its as cut and dry as the US media made it out to be, and what you're repeating here now.

Side: More Unneeded Killing...
Hellno(17753) Disputed
2 points

and what you're repeating here now.

Good grief Garry... I barely said anything.

Side: Rebel Valor!!

Moammar, or Mo (as his friends knew him), has been asking for someone to open up a can on of whup ass on him for quite a long time and it finally happened ;)

Side: Rebel Valor!!
1 point

You aren't going to gain a soul back after killing him. Is it possible to wipe out every mman on this planet that is responsible for odds? Well... Then every politician of India must be killed. My college President must be killed.

I don't say he was God. But. who the hell are we to decide how wrecking and torturous one's life must end? Who is pure enough and has the right justification against oneself or others to make.

It is sad to see Inhumanity... Reminds me of Yeats' ''Second Coming.''

http://www.potw.org/archive/potw351.html

Side: More Unneeded Killing...

Killing a killer doesn't make you not a killer yourself.

Side: More Unneeded Killing...
1 point

Killing a killer doesn't make you not a killer yourself.

Why you killed a killer is the same reason why the killer killed. What I mean is that the forces or the reasons that led you to kill him are the reasons that made him a killer.

i.e in agreement with you!

Side: More Unneeded Killing...

I have a certain amount of respect for man after finding out he stuck it out to the bitter end, don't misunderstand me, i think the man was a tyrant, and he deserved to go although nato was dcompletely illegal in what it did and now they have installed a nice puppet government, but he said he would die fighting and it looks like he did, i think this war would have ended months and months ago had it not been for him staying on and leading the line, that is admirable even though i know many will disagree.

Take for example George W Bush, or Tony Blair, they're willing to fight to last frop of everyone else's blood, Gaddafi may have been crazy but he clearly had principles that he stuck to until the bitter end.

Also, doesn't it strike anyone as odd that this man was for long time a great enemy of the west, a dipsied dictator that wa used to scare the general population and thus justify the west (mainly US) carrying out hanus actions. But then he gave up his WMD and Nuclear programme, and he was the wests darling, Tony Blair even embraced and kissed him, my piont is what kind of impression are we giving to Iran and North Korea, oy yeah don't maike WMD, get rid of the nuclear programme, then we'll pretend to be your friend and then we'll invade. Fucking hypocrisy, how people can buy into this bullshit i will never know, even though i suppose people always have to have a nad guy and a good guy, and there not going to make themselves the bad guy, maybe thats the source of western hypocrisy, doublethink and bias. Peace out, im in a stoic mood.

Side: More Unneeded Killing...
1 point

although nato was dcompletely illegal in what it did and now they have installed a nice puppet government,

Seems like history is down again. Dictatorship in it's true sense of nature is rather hidden by hidden motives.

Fucking hypocrisy, how people can buy into this bullshit

http://ronhullauthor.com/poems/hypocrisy.htm

Side: More Unneeded Killing...
2 points

That was a beautiful and eloquent poem, really captured the point of argument, and then some;-)

Side: More Unneeded Killing...
1 point

It's pointless to kill him. It'd only be reinforcing the loyalist image. And besides, would you prefer a quick, painless death, or a long, grueling, terrible life in prison? Don't let Moammar take the easy way out, make 'em suffer.

Side: More Unneeded Killing...

The death of Gadaffi will only prove disastrous due to the foreign policy of the United States government of interventionist.

Side: More Unneeded Killing...
1 point

Now that he is dead dont be suprised that the next leader is agianst Israel 100 %

Side: More Unneeded Killing...