Ought one receive monetary compensation for donating blood or organs?
Yes
Side Score: 9
|
No
Side Score: 9
|
|
|
|
2
points
2
points
2
points
I am not sure that I fully get your argument. If there is no, for instance, blood available for a person of a certain type, than that person will die. The community will 'miss out' on that person's taxes - which is certainly worth far more than a few bucks which could entice somebody of that type to donate in the first place. A personal choice? I'd say that sperm is one of the most personal things around - yet people buy and sell it as they would an apple or a DVD. Side: yes
I believe that it's okay to either donate or receive money for it. It's yours. If anything is yours, your blood and organs are, and if you don't wish to part with them for free, but you'd still like to help someone, that's your choice. However, in some situations, it is ethically wrong to require money for your blood or organs. For instance, you are going to die in 20 seconds no matter what, requiring money to be donated to your kids to save the person beside you who needs your kidneys might just cause 2 lives to end instead of just the one. So, in short, yes, get money for your blood and organs if you want it and doing so does not cause death, and only in a scenario in which limitations on the profitability of this trade are strictly and morally governed. It should serve as a solid motivator to increase blood and organ stocks, not as a rally cry for cut throat merchants. Side: yes
1
point
1
point
1
point
|
1
point
Do you get money for donating to a charity or to those red salvation army cans during the holidays? Donations are a kindness from the heart not something where you give to receive. You should give so you can know you helped someone. One thing we can all agree on is that if people receive money for donating organs or blood, there would be a large spike by the end of that week in people feeling a little more generous. Side: No
2
points
1
point
Do you get money for donating to a charity or to those red salvation army cans during the holidays? I can recall getting some coupons from some places. Donations are a kindness from the heart not something where you give to receive. What if people with much-needed blood haven't any kindness in their heart? The person who actually needs the blood'll die! One thing we can all agree on is that if people receive money for donating organs or blood, there would be a large spike by the end of that week in people feeling a little more generous. What's so bad about that? It could save many lives! Side: yes
|