CreateDebate


Debate Info

Debate Score:93
Arguments:119
Total Votes:107
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Personally Pro life but pro choice for others. How nice it must be to be a total phoney! (69)

Debate Creator

FromWithin(8241) pic



Personally Pro life but pro choice for others. How nice it must be to be a total phoney!

So tell me why you are personally pro life. The only possible explaination is that you consider that unborn Baby every bit as human as a Baby after birth. Why else would you be personally pro life if you believed it less than human or just tissue.

So tell me, would you not support another's choice to kill their baby's after birth if some judge made it legal? Why is it you would not afford other's the choice to kill Babies after birth if it were legal. Would you vote for politicians who support killing Babies after birth for any reason? You vote for Democrats who support late term abortions for any reason.

All I see when I hear people say they are personally pro life but pro choice for others, is complete phonies who do not possess the guts to tell us they actually could care less about the millions of Babies aborted. They like to pretend having some humanity and compassion.

Add New Argument
7 points

It's as simple as this:

It is entirely possible to dislike something without believing that such should be illegal.

JustIgnoreMe(4290) Clarified
1 point

Banned for this???

1 point

^ Accurate. Except, at least that is marginally entertaining...

3 points

Personally Pro life but pro choice for others. How nice it must be to be a total phoney!

So tell me why you are personally pro life.

You really do sound crazy when you rant as if you're talking to one person, and claim to know so much about others. Of course, there is more that causes this, but it doesn't appear in this snippet.

The only possible explanation is that you consider that unborn Baby every bit as human as a Baby after birth. Why else would you be personally pro life if you believed it less than human or just tissue.

Who says that people who identify as "personally pro-life" (I'm guessing that you're just talking about females in this case) necessarily believe that unborn "babies" (however inaccurate it is to call it a "baby") are less than human?

So tell me, would you not support another's choice to kill their baby's after birth if some judge made it legal? Why is it you would not afford other's the choice to kill Babies after birth if it were legal. Would you vote for politicians who support killing Babies after birth for any reason?

Again, although I don't call myself "personally pro-life", some people aren't single issue voters, and some have moral philosophies that are more nuanced than "stop everyone from doing things that I disapprove of".

That being said, your occasional forgetting to put a question mark over a period suggests that you are more or less completely focused on telling others what they think, and why they are wrong.

You vote for Democrats who support late term abortions for any reason.

Again, you're assuming that people who identify as "personally pro-life" all:

1) Vote.

2) Vote for Democrats.

3) Vote for Democrats who, in particular, support late term abortions, and

4) for any reason whatsoever

I separated the entire thing to show just how many absurd claims you're making about others, simply because they disagree with you somewhat on abortion. You sound bonkers.

All I see when I hear people say they are personally pro life but pro choice for others, is complete phonies who do not possess the guts to tell us they actually could care less about the millions of Babies aborted. They like to pretend having some humanity and compassion.

Ugh, it's couldn't care less. You've been over this with several people. Remember when I told you that you write cringe-worthy stuff? This is one of many examples. You need to start trying harder in your arguments, and start listening to others, because I feel embarrassed just reading this.

Again, who are you to speak for the people who, again, happen to disagree with you somewhat on abortion? It's sad, but unfortunately not unbelievable that you claim to know sooooooo much about other people.

FromWithin(8241) Disputed
1 point

Do you have any idea how many times I cringe when you repeatedly dodge the entire point to constantly insult me with your pathetic demeaning remarks. It's so obvious seeing through the pathetic tactics of those on the Left who want to demonize the Conservative's message. It's like you all take College courses to learn how to twist the truth and lie about the facts to make your laughable arguments seem feasible.

Are you a complete fool or do you refuse to grasp the fact that I am talking to the people on the Left who support the things I speak against. I could care less how many different views and excuses people have for supporting abortion. I'm showing why they are complete phonies. People like you, that this argument was not about, are so paranoid and fearful of the pro life views being espoused to others, you must stick your noses in to spew the laughable excuses for abortions on demand.

The argument is about personally pro life people who support abortion choice for late term abortions. You are pro death so get out of the argument. The fact that you are a narcissistic person who must make himself feel intelligent by pointing out other's mistakes in grammar or their debating skills, makes you a waste of our time.

2 points

One who decry's another's actions while performing those very actions themselves.

I guess that would make you a....Hypocrite!

Oh how I love irony.

Stickers(1037) Disputed
2 points

Do you have any idea how many times I cringe when you repeatedly dodge the entire point to constantly insult me with your pathetic demeaning remarks.

Again, missing a question mark, but hey, you're only talking at me, not with me.

It's so obvious seeing through the pathetic tactics of those on the Left who want to demonize the Conservative's message.

By the standards of pretty much anywhere outside the US, liberals are not on the left, they're center to right-center. US conservatives just happen to be very very right wing in the grand scheme of things, that doesn't make those that don't call themselves conservatives "leftists".

It's like you all take College courses to learn how to twist the truth and lie about the facts to make your laughable arguments seem feasible.

Or, maybe, our arguments have merit and are well reasoned, and you're just dogmatically defending your (fairly narrow) view of the political spectrum?

Are you a complete fool or do you refuse to grasp the fact that I am talking to the people on the Left who support the things I speak against.

The same people who hardly ever resemble this bizarre caricature that you've painted..........

I could care less how many different views and excuses people have for supporting abortion. I'm showing why they are complete phonies.

couldn't

You're conflating not opposing abortion, or supporting more rights and access to abortion with supporting abortion in of itself.

People like you, that this argument was not about, are so paranoid and fearful of the pro life views being espoused to others, you must stick your noses in to spew the laughable excuses for abortions on demand.

Do you see your personal philosophy as edgy and ingenious? You sound like a philistine, FromWithin, I wouldn't be intimidated by your rather goofy view on the nature of personhood, the (alleged) intrinsic value to life, morals, etc . I'm more familiar with these views than you think.

The argument is about personally pro life people who support abortion choice for late term abortions.

You just said 'supporting abortion', or are you really unable to discern the difference between supporting abortion, and disagreeing with the views behind laws banning women from having one?

You are pro death so get out of the argument.

lol, how did you reach that conclusion?

The fact that you are a narcissistic person who must make himself feel intelligent by pointing out other's mistakes in grammar or their debating skills, makes you a waste of our time.

I'm doing more than just critiquing those two things. I'm pointing out your grammatical mistakes and debating style (not skills, there is a difference) because:

1) It makes me cringe, and I just want them to end,

2) some pertain to my arguments regarding how you treat others, and

3) it helps me illustrate just how stubborn and partisan you're being.

Atrag(5666) Banned
3 points

Do you ever ask a question that you don't answer yourself? No of course no that's right you're a republican that always believes in tying people upside down on poles and forcing them to eat their tartare sauce on lemon wedges. They like to pretend they have some humanity and compassion but they are phonies. Fucking lemon wedging republican voters.

Nomoturtle(857) Clarified
1 point

okay, so atrag was a little aggressive here towards republicans, but no more so than you towards people with a different ideology to your own. i dont see any reason to ban atrag any more than there is reason to ban you.

GenericName(3430) Clarified
1 point

Seriously you banned Atrag? What he said is NOTHING compared to what you say about Liberals and Democrats in every thread you come across.

How hypocritical of you. You can dish it out in spades but you can't take it.

FromWithin(8241) Disputed
1 point

Atrag was stalking me attacking every argument I commented on. I told him or her to ignore me because I will not debate someone from another nation who knows nothing of our society.

Please do ban me, I welcome the silence from Liberals who will never admit their faults.

2 points

Lets think about choice in consideration of the conditions that a child in-utero may be diagnosed or born with, for example spina bifida, where depending upon where the lesion is depends the degree of difficulty, then there is downs syndrome where the degree is also dependent upon certain factors. MS is genetically inherited as are many other conditions.

Some newborns will die within a short while because they are unable to survive very long after delivery, this may happen in cases of serious cardiac abnormalities. Many live with surgery and sustain life.

In many cases the quality of life raises ethical questions, and where choice and argument often lay, however, I will always bow to the will, desire, ability and love of the parents who want to give their child the very best quality of life they can no matter the degree.

FromWithin(8241) Disputed
1 point

Are you kidding me? Do you know how many times I've pointed out not to waste our time with your life of mother, extreme cases, blah blah blah to excuse abortions on demand for any reason. HEALTHY MOTHERS, HEALTHY BABIES! That's what I'm talking about!!!!

When you vote for Democrats you are supporting late term abortions for any reason! QUIT WASTING OUR TIME! The GOP already supports extreme cases and life of mother.

You are the phony I speak of. That Baby deserves the right to life and people like you who say it's up to the mother are complete phonies. How would you like someone making it legal to kill you when they deemed your quality of life possibly less than normal?

2 points

What you are talking about is an issue that people don't actually support, hence why people are responding with what people actually DO support.

You are wasting your time on an issue not supported by the Democratic Party's political platform nor the Democratic Party members themselves.

You are talking about a phony issue, over and over.

FromWithin(8241) Disputed
1 point

What kind of fools talk about fetal abnormalities or life of mother abortions, blah blah blah, when in fact the vast vast majority of abortions are purely for reasons of birth control. Can you fools EVER STOP your ludicrous excuses. We are talking about stopping the aborting of healthy babies by healthy mothers. The GOP would love a compromise where only healthy Babies and healthy mother's abortions are illegal. The Democrat would die before excepting anything but abortion on demand for any reason.

I will ban from any of my arguments the next idiot that brings up these rare cases that have nothing to do with the argument.

1 point

Can you point to CLEAN bill (no riders or poison pills) that Republicans have presented to Congress?

And there you are again, censoring differing opinions because you don't like them.

FromWithin(8241) Disputed
1 point

I have a down syndrome brother and guess what? He loves life and is a joy to our family. What kind of inhuman person would condone killing special needs children just because they deem them inferior? You people are beyond having a rational debate. You have no conscience or shame! It's sickening!

Nomoturtle(857) Clarified
1 point

actually this is the sort of opinion you hear from parents themselves who are known carriers for genetic diseases. it is not a hypothetical opinion, it is a part of reality. and it happens more than you might think

Don't you get bored of these pathetic "debate" topics? You just spew the same opinion you have done over and over in an incredibly biased heading and use it as a justification to yell at people.

What's the point?

FromWithin(8241) Disputed
1 point

Why would I ever get bored defending innocent human life. If I can't get inspired over one of the most important issues on Earth, then I might as well be dead inside.

Some people are more passionate over the safety of people who chose to break laws that protected innocent lives of Babies. They said it was not safe for these people in back alleys, or with coat hangers, etc.

Now let me get this straight ok? Those on the Left who supported Abortions cared much more for the safety of those who would abort the Baby, rather than the safety of the Baby itself.

Wow, that is one pathetic misplaced compassion. I would have supported those who wanted rights for life of mother abortions, but nahhh that was cover for their real goals of abortion on demand right up to birth.

Why not make laws for criminals who might get hurt in back alleys when they mug someone. Is that something worth fighting for in your world? Don't worry about the victim.

Whats so sick about pro choice people is they could care less that pro life people have no problem with life of mother abortions. That was suppose to be the entire reasons for stopping back alley abortions. You just can not make this stuff up. Pro choice people seem to lack the most basic humanity and compassion for innocent life.

2 points

I know it really is pointless trying to point out facts to you, but I will try it again: Your concept of life is not universally accepted, and that is the basis for the entire issue.

But keep patting yourself on the back, thinking that yelling at people on a fairly obscure website is "defending innocent human life".

FromWithin(8241) Disputed
1 point

I get bored by idiots who refuse to address the arguments and spend all their time insulting me and how I debate. I am starting to get so bored with it, there might be many more banned from my arguments. I would love to have enjoyable conversations with honest rational people who have the basic understanding of humanity.

Cuaroc(8829) Clarified
2 points

there might be many more banned from my arguments

So much for freedom of speech eh?

Cuaroc(8829) Clarified
2 points

I would love to have enjoyable conversations with honest rational people who have the basic understanding of humanity.

That is just about everyone on this site except for you.

1 point

Go ahead, censor everyone who disagrees with you. Sit alone in a chat room, patting yourself on the back, declaring yourself the only rational person.

Everyone else will just laugh.

Why would I ever get bored defending innocent human life. If I can't get inspired over one of the most important issues on Earth, then I might as well be dead inside.

Some people are more passionate over the safety of people who chose to break laws that protected innocent lives of Babies. They said it was not safe for these people in back alleys, or with coat hangers, etc.

Now let me get this straight ok? Those on the Left who supported Abortions cared much more for the safety of those who would abort the Baby, rather than the safety of the Baby itself.

Wow, that is one pathetic misplaced compassion. I would have supported those who wanted rights for life of mother abortions, but nahhh that was cover for their real goals of abortion on demand right up to birth.

Why not make laws for criminals who might get hurt in back alleys when they mug someone. Is that something worth fighting for in your world? Don't worry about the victim.

Whats so sick about pro choice people is they could care less that pro life people have no problem with life of mother abortions. That was suppose to be the entire reasons for stopping back alley abortions. You just can not make this stuff up. Pro choice people seem to lack the most basic humanity and compassion for innocent life.

1 point

I am neither but understand how others could be without it representing an inherent contradiction. I doubt you could grasp the nuance though. You are more apt to rant incoherently and then ban me like half the other people you have done so to already. So why bother with the effort of explaining what you clearly cannot grasp?

1 point

except it is not just about the baby, and whether someone does not support the legislation behind having an abortion, it is that the mother should have the choice whether or not to raise a child, and having to slave resources during fetal development and eventually massive amounts of their time and effort for a child they do not want is unfair to both the mother and to the child. following that, regardless of whether abortions are legal or not, abortions WILL happen and without the support of a medical professional, many more women will die. and for 'pro-life' movements, where is the research for the number one cause of human death worldwide? miscarriages have not been looked upon whatsoever, despite the view they hold so strongly that life begins as a fetus. from the actions of pro-life parties so far i only see people who only wish to punish women for having unapproved sex.

FromWithin(8241) Disputed
1 point

You know, under your logic, dictators could find a million reasons why certain groups of people should die. He could say they are burdens on society, we can not afford them, many of them might end up becoming murderers and kill innocent mothers, etc. etc. etc. IT'S LUDICROUS! Your making excuses to kill innocent Babies for any reason. GET SOME HUMANITY PLEASE!

GenericName(3430) Clarified
2 points

Do you consider a miscarriage to be manslaughter, out of curiosity?

Nomoturtle(857) Clarified
1 point

go look through some ethical thought experiments and maybe you will see why your idea of absolute right and wrong is ridiculous, even if you did understand the concept of subjectivity, or that other rational ideas can differ from your own. your idea of how rational minded humans operate is ironically more comparable to an insect colony