CreateDebate


Debate Info

3
6
Should be allowed Should be banned
Debate Score:9
Arguments:9
Total Votes:10
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Should be allowed (3)
 
 Should be banned (5)

Debate Creator

TheAshman(2299) pic



Picketing Funerals

Obama has banned the picketing of military funerals, should he have gone further and banned the picketing of all funerals?  With the sad passing this week of Jeff Hanneman Westboro Baptist Church are already talking about picketing his funeral.  Is his family any less deserving  than a soldiers family that people should be allowed to disrupt them during their time of mourning?

Should be allowed

Side Score: 3
VS.

Should be banned

Side Score: 6

The fuckers are dead anyway!

Side: Should be allowed
TheAshman(2299) Disputed
1 point

The mourners aren't should respect to their feelings not be shown?

Side: Should be banned
1 point

What makes them any more valuable than the feelings of the picketers?

Side: Should be allowed

They have the right to assemble just as much as you do. I don't care if it offends you, having something offend you does not give you the authority to take away other's rights.

Besides, these people won't be picketing for much longer, everyone at those funerals is very tempted to go out and kill a few of few of the mental cases outside picketing, once one of them gets killed, the picketing frenzy will die down.

Side: Should be allowed
1 point

All funerals should be a day of reflection and remembrance to ruin that time for somebody is the height of disrespect to the deceased, the attenders and the rest of society.

Side: Should be banned

I totally agree with that, but what about freedom of speech? If people aren't allowed to be jerks at funerals, maybe one day we won't be allowed to be jerks in our own homes.

Side: Should be banned
Axmeister(4322) Clarified
1 point

Uh, sometimes I wish that the term 'freedom of speech' had never been invented and that people just respected other people's views and opinions. The idea that the 'right' to 'freedom of speech' allows an individual to defile the funeral of another person is disgraceful.

Also, you claim that this may infringe on your right to freedom of speech in your home? Because you're equating the 'freedom of speech' which apparently allows people to spoil the private, personal gatherings of other people and the 'freedom of speech' which allows you to express your views in your own private situation.

Side: Should be allowed

I think we should just recycle dead bodies, we waste so much land for cemeteries

Side: Should be banned

In my opinion, picketing at funerals is bad taste and those who are picketing should realize how much they are hurting the family that is mourning.

Side: Should be banned